Showing posts with label mvno. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mvno. Show all posts

Monday, February 23, 2009

Time for a humbler, more focused, wireless wholesale market

The US MVNO market is the greatest missed opportunity I've seen in my wireless career, stretching back almost 20 years. Through carrier resistance and MVNO hubris, a business model that works very well in Europe and Asia has floundered here. Strong, focused MVNOs, which manage their costs and market excellently, improve services and value for wireless users in many places outside the US.

Yet there may be a light flickering in the US market. It's been several years since the meltdowns of Amp'd, Disney Mobile, ESPN and other high-profile players. The iPhone and its imitators have demonstrated the value of a (relatively) open architecture and application environment. And the carriers are still no better at rolling out truly innovative services than they have been.

Plus, nationwide carriers #3 & 4 (Sprint & T-Mobile) trail far behind the leaders in market share. This creates a strategic scenario where a customer acquired by a Sprint or T-Mobile reseller is relatively unlikely to poach the direct business of the wholesaler (and in Sprint's case, they should welcome retaining customers by any means, even if they are transferred to an affiliated wholesaler). Therefore, the perceived opportunity cost of a full-on push into wholesale by these carriers is lower.

Who will be tomorrow's resellers? Those that are laser-focused on markets unserved by the carriers. They will be smaller but profitable, with excellent, low-cost distribution channels. They will be true innovators, bringing high-value applications to their customers. They will have customer bases who purchase phones without subsidies. They will be able to create win-win agreements with the wholesalers.

In a perfect world, a Sprint & T-Mobile push will force AT&T and Verizon to re-enter the wholesale market. Then there will be a strong, vibrant, competitive market where resellers will have some control of their destiny.

And the biggest winner of all will be... the customer. You and I.

Thursday, July 26, 2007

Virgin Mobile inside the numbers, part 2: let's talk about loyalty

Customer loyalty is perhaps the biggest profit driver in wireless--so big, in fact, that your wireless company employs many tools to enforce your loyalty to them. Among them are two- (and sometimes three-) year contracts with large early-termination penalties, handsets locked to use their network only, content you can't port, etc.

Why is loyalty so important in wireless? It comes down to four numbers: ARPU, CPGA, CCPU and Churn.

ARPU stands for Average Revenue per Unit and represents the monthly revenue for each subscriber on the service.

CPGA stands for Cost per Gross Add and is the cost the wireless operator incurs for each customer sign-up.

CCPU stands for Cash Cost per Unit and is the cost per month to support each subscriber.

Churn rate means how many customers disconnect from the service each month.

So, getting to Virgin Mobile. According to their S1 registration filing, here's how they fared on each of those metrics for 2006:

ARPU: $21.48
CPGA: $120.55
CCPU: $13.15
Churn: 4.8%

Massage the above numbers and you can learn some interesting things about Virgin's business. Their monthly gross profit per customer (APRU minus CCPU) is $8.33. They spend $120.55 to sign up a customer. This means that an average customer has to use the service for fifteen months before he becomes profitable. (And a business like Virgin, that's growing substantially, they is signing more new customers up, incurring more CPGA, with fewer old customers generating profits. That leads to net losses in the short term.)

With a churn rate of 4.8%, the average Virgin customer stays on the network a bit less than two years. Meaning there are only six or seven months to make profit from that customer. (Note that Virgin's churn rate is quite a bit lower than a typical prepay operator's churn, which can run upwards of 7% per month, yet is much higher than the postpay operators--e.g., Verizon, Alltel, AT&T--whose churn is around 1.5-3.0% per month, depending on the operator).

One way to summarize this is using a metric called lifetime customer value. According to a model from Harvard Business School, Virgin's lifetime customer value is $30.59. (Here's how I came to that figure. Please check my assumptions and math and let me know if you think anything needs fixing.)

If they could reduce their churn one percentage point, Virgin's lifetime customer value would rise to $64.18. More than double.

And that's why loyalty's important.

(For more on customer loyalty and how it drives the success and failure of businesses, read Fred Reichheld's book, "The Loyalty Effect.")

Tuesday, July 24, 2007

Virgin Mobile inside the numbers, part 1

As Virgin Mobile prepares for its initial public offering, I've been looking through its S1 registration statement. Being the first MVNO to go public in the US, Virgin's S1 opens up an entirely new window to what we know about the MVNO business.

And the first thing to do is to offer a mea culpa. After an MVNO post that I did in May, a reader sent me the following note:

John - I've read your blog. I'm surprised to find you pushing MVNOs. Are any MVNOs aside from Tracfone making money?

Here's my response:
To your question, while there's not much publicly available data on MVNO profitability, I'd wager that Virgin Mobile and Boost are highly profitable.
And my reader, giving me lots of opportunity to backpedal, wrote back, in part:
I don't believe Virgin is yet profitable, though to be honest, I don't follow the industry at all....
Well, it took 30 seconds of looking at the S1 to realize that my reader, who doesn't follow the industry at all, was right, and I was way wrong. Not only is Virgin Mobile not "highly profitable," it is not profitable at all. In its best year, 2006, Virgin lost $37 million on revenue of $1.1 billion.

Fred, time to square up on our wager. Tell me where to send the check.

Tomorrow: looking at Virgin's lifetime customer value

(Photo by rasidk via stock.xchng)

Monday, June 04, 2007

Why did Amp'd Mobile stumble?

It's another day of negative news for the US MVNO industry. One of the highest-profile operators, Amp'd Mobile, filed yesterday for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. According to theWall Street Journal (link - $$), they simply ran out of cash. How did they get to this position?

In the MVNO business (as well as the mobile operator business), customer signups are really expensive. It costs, depending on your distribution model, marketing model, etc., from $100 to $400 to sign up a customer. Meaning it will take perhaps eight to twenty-four months for a subscriber to pay off the initial investment in signing him up.

Established carriers have a large existing customer base to defray the cost of adding new customers. Startups don't. Therefore, they must have enough working capital to absorb these losses until they reach a critical mass of customers. Amp'd apparently didn't.

One other thing. I've heard from some Amp'd subscribers that their bills were late, that they didn't receive bills at all for some months, and in some cases they received bills with an outstanding balance of a penny.

You don't read much about billing in telecoms, as opposed to, say, marketing. But late bills, missing bills, etc., cause customers to withhold or delay payment. A carrier with these issues leaves money on the table--money that could help pay its bills while it waits for those new customers to turn positive. It's not clear how much this impacted Amp'd's situation, but it was a factor for sure.

Marketing is sexy, but collecting money from customers? That's priceless.

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

Qualcomm plans health-care-focused MVNO

MVNOs, or privately-branded wireless operators, continue to make slow but steady progress in the USA. The latest announced today is LifeComm, a company spun out of wireless giant Qualcomm, which reportedly will operate over the Verizon Wireless network. Read the Wireless Week story here.

Health is an ideal niche for MVNOs to target, given the huge expenditures in healthcare and the ability to create wireless applications that help users better manage their health. (This company, though not an MVNO, has an interesting wireless health application for diabetics.) A barrier to this point has been carriers allowing MVNOs to use the full richness of the 3G application environments to develop applications that could compete with those of their carrier hosts.

For Qualcomm, provider of Verizon's wireless application environment Brew, that was apparently not a problem.

Monday, May 07, 2007

Private-label cellular service arrives

Have you ever wanted your company's name on a cellphone service? For many clubs, charitable causes, etc., mobile service, used daily by nearly everyone, is a highly attractive product to offer to their members.

Today's Wall Street Journal discusses this market (free link), focusing on Sonopia, one of the companies providing a platform for clubs to resell mobile service.

The concept isn't brand new. Working Assets, a progressive political group, has been offering long distance service for nearly two decades and wireless since 2000. It recently announced that it is providing the platform for Planned Parenthood to offer its own branded mobile service. But Sonopia's recent launch has been the most visible to date.

The affinity group's value proposition to its members is as follows: cellphone service is a commodity, and if you have to buy a commodity somewhere, you might as well buy it from a group you care about (us), and channel some of the money (around 5%) our way.

More than this, though, the organizations feel they can deepen connections with their communities, both by having a logo on a product used daily and by having the ability to communicate with their constituents in a real-time, always-on manner.

But no one wants to do it at a loss, and even if cellphone service is a commodity, Verizon, Sonopia and the affinity group all want their piece of the pie. The question then is: will there be enough money to go around? And how many people will give up their Cingular family plan for a Yoga phone?

Time will tell whether private-label mobile phones are a long-term success, or merely a passing fad.

, , , , ,

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

US MVNOs - what viable concepts remain?

The US MVNO market has passed through infancy. Some MVNOs are entering adolescence (Virgin, Boost) while others are just starting to walk on their own (Helio, Amp'd, Disney). Discount prepaid operators are beginning to see a shakeout (see this news item). Which all begs the question: are there any new MVNO types that still have life? I think there are two:

  1. The "store-brand" MVNO - if you are a large enough retailer, with a devoted clientele, and don't already stock other cellphones, a prepaid offering can be profitable. The prototype operator is Tesco Mobile in the UK.

  2. The cult MVNO - how do you lure customers away from the large mobile operators? One way is to have a powerful, long-lasting bond with a segment of customers. And tell them: "Buy cellphone service from us. It may cost a little more, you may have to give up a little service, but it's worth it to support the community." One very recent example is the launch of the Planned Parenthood MVNO.
Store-brand MVNOs will be larger, but fewer in number, since a limited number of retail channels will fulfill the criteria to host a successful MVNO. Cult MVNOs, by contrast, will serve smaller subscriber bases, but could be much more numerous.

And, of course, one significant question remains: will the operators want to enable them?

(Photo: the LG225 phone offered by Planned Parenthood Wireless)

, , , , ,

Monday, September 25, 2006

What the hell is an MVNO?

This week I'll be blogging from the MVNO Strategies & Markets Conference in New York (registration information here if you're interested). The posts will be more narrowly-focused than normal. Therefore, to orient our non-telecom-professional readership, I'll need to provide some background.

MVNO stands for Mobile Virtual Network Operator. In the old analog days, that meant cellular reseller; i.e., a company that resold cellular service under its own name. Three major changes have occurred in the US and many other markets around the world that have enabled this old reseller market to reform into what we now call MVNO.

  1. Digital cellular has replaced analog. With that transformation has come more open standards, such as GSM, CDMA and various advanced intelligent network (AIN) protocols. This has opened up wireless network technology to new suppliers and, important for the MVNO market, improved the ability for partners of the network operators.

  2. Creation of multiple, nationwide carriers. Both modifiers are important. Multiple network operators (preferably three or more) create a competitive environment that incents carriers to resell excess capacity to MVNOs. Nationwide coverage allows MVNO to sell service most everywhere in a country with a single carrier agreement, an important simplification that improves the marketing leverage of an MVNO and also reduces cost.

  3. Investment in wireless data infrastructure. Carriers throughout the world have spent tens of billions of dollars on 3G infrastructure. Gaining a return on that investment is important and again incents carriers to bring in MVNO partners.

The result has been an explosion of MVNOs around the world. Tesco, a grocer, has brought on millions of prepaid clients in the UK. Disney has created a specialized mobile family application that it is selling in the US. And PLDT from the Philippines provides service to hundreds of thousands of Filipino expatriates in Hong Kong and soon in Singapore.

Will MVNOs remain an important part of the wireless landscape? Or will the marginal ones fade away, and the strongest merely become subsidiaries of the ever-growing carriers? We'll have to stick around for a few years to know.


, ,