Thursday, May 24, 2007

Silos part 2: the importance of connection

Earlier this week, I posted on an article by Ranjay Gulati of Northwestern University in this month's Harvard Business Review, "Silo Busting: How to Execute on the Promise of Customer Focus" (link - $$). Gulati brings up another area in which companies are adjusting to provide solutions that better fit customer needs: increasing connections between companies.

It's an accepted fact that more and more companies are pursuing alliances to extend their capabilities or to shed noncore functions. Gulati reinforces what often gets lost in all the talk about alliances: these moves occur primarily because it helps companies deliver solutions that customers will buy.

Extended capabilities help fill out solutions that would be incomplete with only the company's own products. Outsourcing helps companies reduce their unit costs, thereby enabling more cost-effective solutions, and allows them to focus more investment and management attention on activities that are more central to serving customers (like account management).

Relying more on partners has a downside. A company can become too dependent on partners and suppliers. It can grow competitors by educating other companies about its business. And managing cooperation is more difficult between two different companies with their own strategies and cultures than it is between different departments of the same company.

But the extended firm is here to stay. If you don't think you can manage alliances, you better get some education quick.

(Photo: "Silo2" by saulinis via stock.xchng)

Wednesday, May 23, 2007

Web 2.0 gives a new meaning to works-in-progress

You can't see it till it's finished
David Byrne, "Artists Only"

There was a time when writers, musicians, artists went "deep in the shed" (search this page for a definition) and emerged, months or years later, with completed masterworks.

No more. Now books, records, presentations, etc., are previewed and assembled online, for all to see. First drafts, alternate endings, even books created with input from the audience are de rigueur. In a recent "Fresh Air," from National Public Radio, drummer Paul Motian remarked on how appalled the late pianist (and perfectionist) Bill Evans would be with the "complete box set" (including alternate takes, restarts, etc.) of the Village Vanguard sessions released in 2005.

In some way, this trend echoes the time-honored academic approach of circulating drafts of scholarly papers among a group of peers for comment. Of course, now the peer group is everybody with an internet connection.

It's another way, I suppose, in which we are more exposed to the world. Our privacy is reduced, at our own initiative. But it's fun, too. Not in an exhibitionistic way, but in a trusting, welcoming way. With more of our foibles, mistakes, and misunderstandings out in the open, perhaps we are more human, and the distance between us shortens a little bit.

(Photo: Talking Heads Japanese newspaper article by artlung via flickr. Creative Commons attribution license)


Tuesday, May 22, 2007

Shop Talk Podcast #1 - Gordon Adams on "Time Kills Deals"

OK, it's time for something new. I've been fascinated by podcasting for a couple of years now, and almost got involved with a podcasting project last fall. So I've been thinking about a regular podcast on this site, and it's time to unveil it.

This was a one-take, unedited interview. I recorded it using an inexpensive conference-calling technology which overcompressed the thing, so as a result I sound like I'm from Chicago (no, Connecticut) and that I have a lisp (also no). Nonetheless it was fun to do and I'd like to do more. They'll improve technically for sure.

Anyway, onto the podcast. My guest is Gordon Adams, Senior Vice President of Sales at Vue Technology, a maker of item-level RFID solutions. (Read Gordon's bio here.)

We're talking about "Time Kills Deals," an expression I first heard from Gordon when I worked with him at EDS in 1995. It's a great, pithy maxim that I've used ever since (and blogged about here). I'd love your comments. Enjoy!

(Please be patient through the 10 seconds of dead air at the beginning of the podcast... ah, the joys of being a beginner!)

Download podcast

Links to companies or products referred to in the podcast:

EDS
Holden International
Solution Selling

Errata:

1. In the podcast, I refer to Gordon's company as "Vue Technologies." It is, of course, Vue Technology.
2. Gordon was the USC starting quarterback for only one year (I implied it was several years).

(Photo: "Vintage 1" by coscurro via stock.xchng)

Monday, May 21, 2007

For solutions providers, Account Management is king

Every product company wants to sell solutions. Packaging products with useful complementary services can elevate a firm above commodity-provider status and provide more value to customers. Customized solutions also are more difficult for competitors to replace than standalone products.

Moving to a solution focus is not easy to do, of course. Ranjay Gulati of Northwestern University takes up the issue in his article, "Silo Busting: How to Execute on the Promise of Customer Focus" (link - $$), in the May Harvard Business Review. Prof. Gulati focuses on issues that most large product companies face when trying to move to a solution orientation--specifically, that solutions typically span multiple groups (or "silos"). Selling and delivering a coordinated solution requires close cooperation between those groups--an unnatural act in most large companies.

What most struck me was his observation that customers worry because the account managers they are assigned don't have the clout to influence the groups contributing to these integrated solutions. And this worry is not misplaced: my experience with large companies indicates that only very senior people can drive coordination among separate business units that manage their own P&L. Writes Gulati of one company that succeeded in selling solutions across division boundaries:

The account management group was staffed with high-ranking officers who had the authority to negotiate the pricing and delivery of [its] solutions, and the experience to help clients with strategic planning.

Dedicating senior people to a strategic account management role is a large investment for companies. But if you want to move from a product focus to an integrated solution focus, it's one you have to make.

(Photo: "Silo2" by saulinis via stock.xchng)

Friday, May 18, 2007

A prospect makes up his mind

Usually I'm selling things, but today I bought something. It was time to get a new accountant, and I had to choose between two. What were the reasons I chose the one I did? Here are my impressions as a prospect of each one.

Accountant A:

  • recommended by a friend
  • had reasonable fees
  • had a very nice, funny (middle-aged) receptionist
  • at our meeting, took out a pad of paper and began sketching out ideas and discussing them as we talked
  • was dressed like me (polo shirt and khakis)
  • spoke as if he knew what he was talking about
  • talked to me as a peer
  • was the first one I met with
Accountant B:
  • recommended by a friend
  • had reasonable fees
  • at our meeting, asked me a lot of questions about my business
  • wore a suit
  • asked me to explain my typical customer engagement
  • talked to me as a peer
  • was the second one I met with
Can you guess that I chose Accountant A? When you look at my impressions of each one, there's lots of similarity. I think I would have been well served by either. At the end of the day, him taking out the pad of paper and working the solution with me interactively was probably the clincher.

Of course, I can't dismiss the fact that Accountant A had already set my mind in motion, so it's distinctly possible I didn't give Accountant B a fair chance. He might have been ready to pull out the pad of paper just as I stood up to leave.

The lessons for us sales types:
  • buying decisions are emotional
  • prospects aren't fair
  • it's better to go first and set the ground rules for the competition
  • prospects may make up their mind on the littlest things--be completely aware of how you come across
And an engaging receptionist is worth her weight in gold.

Thursday, May 17, 2007

Strategic marketing leverages content, connection, community

John Jantsch's blog "Duct Tape Marketing," focused on the small businessperson, pops up with a killer post on occasion (the rest of the time, it's a bit too commercial, with lots of plugs for his book and others' products). One of the really good posts was yesterday: "Are You Investing in Long Term Marketing?"

In it, he challenges entrepreneurs to focus on the marketing projects that will pay off in the long run--even if in the short run they seem to drain away lots of time. They include

  • content (blogs, white papers, etc.)
  • connection (deeper ties with prospects, colleagues, influencers, mentors, etc.)
  • community (board engagements, local fundraising, etc.)

When I read this post and looked back at the (short) history of my business, I realized that I've gotten every single client via my Rolodex. No exceptions. Either they've been a direct contact or referred by a direct contact. How does my Rolodex grow? By meeting people and gaining their trust through content, connection or community.

Meaning, for me, if I'm making a marketing investment that's not focused on expanding the value or size of my Rolodex, it's simply misplaced.

(Photo by spekulator via stock.xchng)

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

Qualcomm plans health-care-focused MVNO

MVNOs, or privately-branded wireless operators, continue to make slow but steady progress in the USA. The latest announced today is LifeComm, a company spun out of wireless giant Qualcomm, which reportedly will operate over the Verizon Wireless network. Read the Wireless Week story here.

Health is an ideal niche for MVNOs to target, given the huge expenditures in healthcare and the ability to create wireless applications that help users better manage their health. (This company, though not an MVNO, has an interesting wireless health application for diabetics.) A barrier to this point has been carriers allowing MVNOs to use the full richness of the 3G application environments to develop applications that could compete with those of their carrier hosts.

For Qualcomm, provider of Verizon's wireless application environment Brew, that was apparently not a problem.

A more realistic way to profit from innovation

Most big companies' innovation processes look like this: sort through a host of new-venture proposals, select the one with the biggest payback and lowest risk, and fund it through launch. Establish ongoing "go/no-go" checkpoints to ensure the venture is meeting its projections and, if it's not, kill it.

While it sounds reasonable, this kind of process contributes to the poor return on innovation investment in many businesses. So say Rita Gunther McGrath of Columbia Business School and Thomas Keil of Helsinki University of Technology in an article in the May Harvard Business Review ("The Value Captor's Process" - link $$).

The key defect in standard innovation processes is a belief that the initial business plan for a venture is unalterable and that the only success is fulfilling the business plan as originally conceived. This leaves no room for the reality of an innovation process--which is that there may be several possible successful outcomes, and achieving any one will add value to the company.

McGrath and Keil suggest several other ways to extract value from new ventures if "Plan A" doesn't come about:

  • Recycling. To entrepreneurs, shifting course based on new possibilities or issues discovered during the development process is second nature. To large companies, it's a very difficult task. Of one new-business venture, the authors write, "The applications that turned out to be significant profit generators were not on the original list of possibilities."

  • Spinning off/licensing. If your company can't make a go of it, perhaps an outsider can, with the company potentially retaining some ownership.
  • Spinning in. If the venture doesn't stand alone, it may be a useful extension to an existing business unit.

  • Salvaging. At worst, put the learnings and technology gained in the venture to work somewhere in the company.

The authors also focus on an alternate approach to new-venture planning. They write:

An alternative to the go/no-go approach is to make learning a central purpose of the venture plan. In a discovery-driven plan, measuring progress consists of validating assumptions as quickly and cheaply as possible and then revising the plan as necessary at key milestones.

Such planning allowed Texas Instruments to enter the RFID market very early, testing the market and value propositions inexpensively and cautiously, but then being prepared when large-scale markets for the products emerged. "Had TI based its decision to invest in the venture on whether the market size and potential payback were sufficiently large and the level of risk sufficiently low," write McGrath and Keil, "the company probably would not have funded the initial effort."

(Photo by lusi via stock.xchng)

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

CEOs can no longer sit out the sales process

A CEO used to be able to sit in his office suite in the "God Pod" and issue proclamations. No longer. Now he has to get on the road and sell. And not the "glad to meet you" meetings he used to have. He is rolling up his sleeves, solving customer problems and committing the company to deliver.

So says the Wall Street Journal in its recent "In The Lead" column. Paul Otellini of Intel is one of the CEOs profiled, and it's instructive that at one of the techiest of tech companies, the CEO is a former salesperson. The article states:

Top executives like Mr. Otellini find they are working more closely than ever with their customers, and listening and responding to their requests for product customization or service and training. They are becoming involved even in the nitty-gritty of contract negotiations.
I've sold in environments where the CEO didn't want to get his hands dirty, and others where he was willing to do anything we asked to help close a sale. The former was easier on the sales team (fewer tough questions from the CEO!). The latter, as you can imagine, was far more effective in winning business.

And it was much easier to overcome internal challenges with the client project when all the operating groups knew the CEO was personally invested in the deal.

Monday, May 14, 2007

Pentagon uses stories to provide ethical guidance

A Pentagon ethics official has found the perfect way to teach government employees about their thicket of ethical regulations. Tell stories.

That's right. Stephen Epstein, Director of the Pentagon's Standards of Conduct Office, has spent the past five years compiling a document called "The Encyclopedia of Ethical Failure." It contains more than a hundred stories of bureaucratic misbehavior, including one in which a Marine lent his government credit card to a friend who made $13,000 of purchases with it.

Mr. Epstein and his Encyclopedia were the subjects of a front page article in today's Wall Street Journal (link - $$). According to the article,

Mr. Epstein says he was inspired to create the Encyclopedia by a Navy magazine that used humor to discuss aviation mishaps. He recalls an account of a fighter pilot who took off, only to realize that his plane's wings were still folded. "These were stories that got your attention and had a strong message, a parable," he says.

The Encyclopedia's users are equally sold on the concept that stories can educate better than rules:
Patrick Carney, assistant general counsel for ethics at the Federal Communications Commission, draws on the Encyclopedia for training and encourages his staff to read the document online because the "bite-size examples are more entertaining than reading the statutes" themselves, he says. In quarterly internal FCC "Ethicsgram" newsletters, Mr. Carney includes items from the Encyclopedia. "Everyone around town is looking for ways to get the word out on ethics, and Steve's material is often used," he says.
Mr. Epstein provides a good example to others trying to convey increasingly complex ethical principles to their employees. Rulesbooks are either far too detailed or too sketchy to provide guidance . Narrative expert Dave Snowden argues that documenting worst practice is more useful and effective than trying to instill "best practice" in any complex area.

Stephen Epstein would agree.

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox


Friday, May 11, 2007

I don't get it... can you draw me a picture?

A few years ago, I was working on a large sales opportunity with AT&T. During our first meeting with them we had a lot of discussion about the requirements for the project, what the users were trying to get out of it, technical details of the systems & integration points & so forth. I spent most of my time at the white board sketching out a rough diagram, the way our new system would interconnect to their existing systems. The diagram was recreated in Visio and became a feature of every subsequent meeting, the basis of every discussion about integration and interconnection, with changes continually incorporated. And reviewing the diagram became the way we'd orient new people to the project.

After that, we required a similar diagram be created for each project and be included in every proposal.

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox