Showing posts with label branding. Show all posts
Showing posts with label branding. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

P&G, in moving into services, can learn lessons from Disney



NOTE: We will stop posting new material to this blog location as of Friday, Feb 27. Please visit our new home, which also contains the complete archive of posts. If you'd like to update your RSS reader, here's the feed for the new place.


I read with interest the recent HBR Editors' Blog posting speculating on the difficulties Procter & Gamble might run into in its effort to create a chain of car wash franchises, called Mr. Clean Performance Car Wash.

When I read the post, written by marketing professors Neeli Bendapudi, Randle D. Raggio and Tassu Shervani, we were in the midst of a vacation in Orlando, Florida, at the various Disney parks. So, the connection between what P&G is trying to do now and what Walt Disney kicked off some fifty years ago came to me instantly.

The upshot of the HBR post is that product and services businesses are dramatically different, in particular the need for a service business to deliver an experience over and over again, consistently and of high quality, despite the innate variability of people, locations and customers.

With this in mind I monitored my Disney experience for the rest of the week for lessons that could help P&G.


  1. Brand gets people to try your service; blocking and tackling gets them to return. The Disney properties flaunt the characters, movies and TV shows at every turn. Yet after an hour at the park, you notice that trash cans are always close by, so that if you have an empty cup or candy wrapper, you don't end up holding it for more than a few seconds before finding a place to discard it. As a result, the park is exceptionally clean for a place holding tens of thousands of guests.

  2. No detail is too small. Kids are royalty at Disney (a significant differentiator compared to most places where they are seen as messy, noisy attention-seekers--which, of course, they are). The bag checkers, waitresses, salespeople--in short, every "cast member" we encountered--took special care of our kids.

  3. Consistency reduces stress. Each of the four Disney parks we visited had a similar parking scheme, shuttle bus protocal, and entry design. Which meant there was very little standing around head-scratching and wondering which gate to go through or which bus to board.

  4. Customer recognition builds loyalty. Everywhere in the parks I saw guests wearing buttons saying "My First Time!" or "It's My Birthday Today!" These simple gestures to recognize guests made their experiences special, built warm memories, and encouraged them to return.


I'm rooting for P&G in their Mr. Clean car wash project. The above lessons are like much good advice--easy to understand, hard to implement. Whether P&G can execute, and the marketplace and the economy cooperate, only time will tell.

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Customers are talking - Tropicana hears feedback, brings back old carton

Sometimes the roar of customer feedback can force a multi-million dollar capitulation. Today, the New York Times reported that Tropicana, a unit of PepsiCo, was responding to a wave of negative customer feedback to its recent change in packaging. The Times writes:


Redesigned packaging that was introduced in early January is being discontinued, executives plan to announce on Monday, and the previous version will be brought back in the next month.

Also returning will be the longtime Tropicana brand symbol, an orange from which a straw protrudes. The symbol, meant to evoke fresh taste, had been supplanted on the new packages by a glass of orange juice.

The about-face comes after consumers complained about the makeover in letters, e-mail messages and telephone calls and clamored for a return of the original look.


Some online reaction to the new Tropicana package is here and here. (And, to be sure we stay fair and balanced, here is a rave review of the new package.)

One wonders what kind of testing process Tropicana used for the new packaging. I would hope that they used the approach that online services use today--which is to roll out new looks to a limited audience and listen carefully to the feedback before rolling things out across their base. But if so, they would have gotten this feedback far faster and before it became a national news item.

Packaged-goods companies tend to be secretive with their makeovers, often keeping details hidden until a widely publicized, nationwide rollout. The result of this strategy, though, is not hearing feedback, positive or negative, until a great deal of investment has been committed. Meaning a rollback, like Tropicana's doing, is terribly expensive (and highly-publicized).

I wonder how Tropicana will handle their next packaging change?

Thursday, December 13, 2007

Re-branding: an oxymoron?

I recently saw a to-do list on the wall at a company's marketing department. At the top of the list was "re-branding." And I've been thinking about that for some days. What is re-branding?

At companies I'm familiar with, it means redoing the logo, new taglines, new color schemes for the website, new ad campaigns, etc. But the more I've thought about that to-do list, the more I've come to think that re-branding is a misnomer for this type of activity.

The outward characteristics of a brand don't mean much if they don't reflect the intrinsic characteristics of the company and its offerings. An old, staid company with a sleek modern logo hasn't added anything to its brand except perhaps confusion. It's hard to put into a formula, but I'd say something like

Brand = Company History + Customer Perceptions + Noncustomer Perceptions + Impact of (Advertising & Publicity)


The re-branding exercise most directly affects the latter, and, over time, noncustomer perceptions as well. It can't contradict company history or customer perceptions, so a complete reinvention of the brand is not possible.

Assuming equal weight to each, "re-branding" as it's understood by marketing people can alter your brand image up to 25%. It, of course, has the advantage that it can be executed by the marketing department--without the challenge of rewriting history and changing customers' perceptions.

So don't call it "re-branding." Call it "new logo," perhaps, or "new look." And be careful that your re-branding exercise doesn't distract you from the long, hard work of truly strengthening your brand. That takes more than the marketing department to do.

It takes everybody.

, ,

Saturday, March 31, 2007

Don' forget to love your own company's brands

I had a web hit from someone at Microsoft today, and what I thought was funny was that the searcher used Google.com. That reminded me of a story.

Way back I got my dream summer job, an internship at IBM, and my first day in the office my boss asked me to make a copy of a bunch of documents, so I went to one of the other people in my office and I said, "Hey, can you tell me where the Xerox machine is?" He responded, "We make copiers here."

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox


,

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

The value of B2B brands

Jon Miller of the Marketo blog has a very powerful post refuting some people's belief that B2B brands don't matter, and that investing in brand-building is a waste of money for B2B companies.

I'd go as far as to say that anyone who thinks that brands don't matter in business-to-business sales hasn't sold to many businesses. And certainly hasn't been involved in buying much for their companies.

In my experience, selling with a well-established brand behind me is much easier than selling an unknown brand. And buying a well-established brand conveys stability, longevity, predictability and a measure of security.

By way of the evidence of B2B brands' value, I'd point readers to the March Harvard Business Review, in which James Gregory of CoreBrand and Donald Sexton of Columbia University describe their method for calculating the brand equity of business-to-business companies. (A free copy is available by following this link.) Sexton and Gregory concluded there were significant deltas in brand equity between leading companies and lagging companies across many B2B industry groups. For instance, in the Office Equipment category, brand equity ranged from 18.37% of market cap (highest) to 4.26% of market cap (lowest).

If B2B brands are meaningless, how then to explain the differences in brand equity these statistics illustrate?

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox

Monday, March 12, 2007

PGA Tour has lost its sense...of branding

Sports marketing has been careening toward the cliff of excess for some time now (the wall-to-wall corporate sponsorship depicted in "Talladega Nights" was more verisimilitude than parody). But the recent revolving door of sponsor-named events in the US PGA golf tour is seriously damaging the history and heritage of US professional golf.

The latest example is something called the PODS Championship, held this past weekend in Florida. (PODS stands for Portable On-Demand Storage, in the form of a shipping container that this company drops in your front yard for you to fill with stuff, where it sits till your house project is done, much to the delight of your neighbors.)

The PODS Championship used to be the Chrysler Championship, and was held in the fall, not in early March. It's always been in the Tampa area, but you wouldn't know that from any of the communication surrounding the event. In fact, for all I knew (and I'm a golf fan!), this was a brand-spanking new event.

I could have said the same thing about the Wachovia Championship, the Fry's Electronics Open, the Buick Classic, the Buick Open or the Buick Invitational, not to mention the late, great 84 Lumber Classic. (Some of these were events with history, and some were new. See if you can guess which!)

What ever happened to the Westchester Classic, the Western Open, or the Firestone Tournament of Champions? At least AT&T was smart enough to retain part of the historical name of its tournament (the AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am).

Exclusive naming rights bring tens of millions of dollars yearly to the PGA Tour, helping purses to grow tenfold between 1986 and 2006, according to GolfWorld. But at some point they'll be ruing the day the good old Greater Hartford Open became the Travelers.

Monday, March 05, 2007

Everything you ever wanted to know about private labels: What I'm reading now #3

Unless you're a consumer-packaged-goods marketer or retailer, you probably have no idea how pervasive private labels have become in the stores you frequent. But the next time you go to the drugstore, see if you pick up a bottle of Aleve or the CVS naproxen sodium placed right next to it.

Professors Nirmalya Kumar of London Business School and Jan-Benedict Steenkamp of Duke University have satisfied the curiosity of everyone who ever wanted to know about private-label goods by writing Private Label Strategy: How to Meet the Store Brand Challenge.

According to the authors, the opportunities for private labels are vast, and the challenges to branded goods are daunting. Private label goods provide a point of differentiation for the retailer (such as Target or Tesco), and they create powerful leverage when negotiating terms with brand manufacturers.

Leading packaged-goods companies, like Procter and Gamble, Unilever and Nestle, are responding to the challenge. How? Four main ways:

  1. partnering with retailers to produce exclusive specialty offerings
  2. innovating like crazy to stay ahead of copycat private-label offerings
  3. divesting laggard brands
  4. increasing investment in advertising and marketing for the brands they retain
To point (4), the authors point out a most interesting development: as a result of the increasing size and scale of retailers, brand manufacturers' marketing dollars have been drawn away from advertising and other brand-building activities toward point-of-purchase and promotion investments. The latter help the retailer and sales (in the short term), but at the cost of the long-term value of the product--and as a side effect improving the prospects for private-label copycats.

The book is essential reading for any consumer-packaged goods companies or retailers, and for anyone else who wants to study up on a dimly-lit corner of the marketing world.

, , , , ,

Tuesday, February 27, 2007

Story v. Essay

It's becoming conventional wisdom that stories are a superior form of communication for complex information, such as strategies, value of technology products, business knowledge, brand attributes, etc. (Don't believe me? Read these: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8.)

Here's a simple way to distinguish a story from another form of communication, the essay (which works well in other situations):

Story Essay
engages the senses engages the mind
concrete, detailed abstract/conceptual
specific general
contains moment-to- moment action. (“Thomas flicked his finger, causing his pen to twirl around his thumbnail until he caught it again.”) summarized (“Students are often bored in school.”)
suspenseful, surprising linear
uses action verbs “is”

Wait, you're saying. Don't some stories have the same characteristics as the essays you're referring to?

Yes. But they're rarely good stories.

(Picture by kaliyoda via stock.xchng)

, , , , ,