Thursday, May 10, 2007

Garry Shandling on interviewing by letting people talk

I recently listened to an episode of National Public Radio's "Fresh Air" in which David Bianculli interviews Garry Shandling, the creator of the "Larry Sanders Show," about the DVD set that's just been released.

Shandling included lots and lots of new content in the DVD collection consisting of him talking to various friends (Alec Baldwin, Jerry Seinfeld). I found it inspiring the way that he brought each person to a meaningful location, and entered into a dialogue, rather than "interviewing" them. He mentions in the Fresh Air interview that he finds magic in the moment, in the back and forth of him and the subject, and that a more scripted, formal approach would be less fresh and interesting.

That says a lot to people like me considering how to "do" podcasting. I may give his approach a try.

will narrative techniques work in today's business world?

If you stop by here regularly, you may be aware that I've spent the past few months rediscovering my love of storytelling and exploring how it can be used as a business tool. In addition to numerous posts on the subject (a collection can be found here), I've worked with Shawn Callahan of Anecdote, the Australian company that is one of the pioneers in discovering and using an organization's stories to help it understand and improve its business.

I'm a believer in gathering and making sense of stories as a radically new way to harness the contributions of the entire employee base for the benefit of the company's learning, strategizing and management.

But there's one question I've made no progress in answering for myself. Can a service like this, which takes account of the opinion and experience of everyone in the company, work when seemingly every company is downsizing, rightsizing, outsourcing or otherwise disrupting its relationship with its employees?

Can you do the narrative stuff while a company's going through that kind of change?

Well, outsourcing, downsizing, rightsizing, restructuring, etc., are not going away. It will take true leadership from the CEO (that is, it's a responsibility too important to hope that a subordinate takes it up) to create an environment that allows deep learning and knowledge sharing to go on in the midst of all the "-ings."

Succeed at that, Ms. CEO, and you'll have earned your pay package.

Wednesday, May 09, 2007

To succeed with a new idea, engage your opponents

Imagine that you want to build a manufacturing plant using cutting-edge green technology: a living roof, solar panels, a permeable parking lot and natural stormwater filtration system. Whom do you want as your project manager?

According to Bill McDonough, the architect responsible for Ford's Rouge River plant redesign, it's someone who thinks the project is a bad idea. McDonough said so in a speech at last year's Fortune Innovation Forum.

Please stop laughing and read this quote from May's Harvard Business Review. It's from "Even Commodities Have Customers," the story of how Francois Jacques created a high-value marketing function at the world's largest cement maker.

I told you, stop laughing. Here's the quote:


I felt there would be support within the division for investment in marketing capabilities if I could demonstrate to people on the front lines that top management was really serious. I decided to begin be getting one or two divisional executives to assume some formal sponsorship role for the program. I was looking for a couple of top executives to share responsibility for the program's success or failure....

Two people...took strong positions. One told me that my plan was far too ambitious to have any hope of succeeding. The other was supportive. Looking at the profiles of each man, I realized that I had found both of my sponsors.

My instinctual reaction, when faced with opposition, is to surmount it or sidestep it (or dismiss it). McDonough's and Jacques' strategy, instead, was to embrace the opponent.

Don't do it my way. As counterintuitive as their approaches are, both McDonough and Jacques realized two very important things: active opposition equals engagement. And winning over the opponent sends a powerful signal to others that the idea has merit. [And another thing: steamrollering an opponent will guarantee he becomes a fierce enemy of the idea.]

It's crucial, though, to ensure you understand why the opponent is against the idea, and to know that the opposition is based on reasons that you can address--rather than opposition that's based on personality or power plays. Lafarge writes:

[The opponent's] extreme response indicated that he was engaged with the idea, and... I learned that much of his apparent hostility stemmed from past bad experiences with marketing in another division of Lafarge.

I'll leave you with another paraphrase from McDonough's speech.

"Vocal opponents can be your best allies. The passive resisters you've got to get rid of."

(Photo by CraigPJ via stock.xchng)

, , ,

Tuesday, May 08, 2007

Collecting and organizing narratives makes sense of complex problems

When I discuss my latest project, improving organizational performance via collecting and making sense of the narratives that employees carry with them, most people are initially skeptical. And organizational development professionals are often the quickest to dismiss the approach as "more of the same."

So why am I convinced that narrative collection, selection, and sensemaking will work better than existing methods of gathering and acting on metrics, surveys and executive intuition?

It's all about complexity. By now, we've ERPed, Six-Sigma'ed, Re-engineered, Rightsized, Business-Intelligenced and Job Sculpted our companies. Basic problems, such as systematizing processes, ensuring consistency of actions, enforcing policies and procedures, have largely been solved.

The problems that remain are messier, stickier, and more ambiguous, because they are more about people and their innate complexity. Difficulties in communicating, understanding each other, managing egos. Problems of company strategy, culture, management of change and managerial decisionmaking. Identifying and making use of organizational wisdom. These problems don't have rote solutions. They don't even have optimal solutions. In fact, there may be many outcomes that work well and equally many that are undesirable.

So, back to narrative. Creating stories about ourselves and our surroundings has been used since the beginning of history to make sense of and help us deal with our messiest, most daunting problems (check out this bestselling book for some examples).

One example I know of perfectly demonstrates the narrative technique. Underground, by the Japanese author Haruki Murakami, intends to make sense of the senseless--the Aum Shinrikyo cult's sarin gas attack on the Tokyo subway in 1995.

It does so by collecting and presenting stories. Thirty-four victims of the attack describe the day and its aftermath, in moment-to-moment detail. Eight cult members talk about their involvement and their feelings while perpetrating the atrocity.

The author is invisible, except for a brief prologue and small essay midway through. His task was to interview the survivors and cult members, select and edit the stories, and lay them out.

Reading this book is as close to being there that day as you could imagine. And the series of narratives, one laid on top of another, greatly illuminates the surprise and panic, the lingering fear and dread and perseverence, that being part of such an event brings on.

It's indescribable, unsummarizable, this book. And that's the point. A carefully-collected, organized collection of stories can bring an understanding of the most complex situations in a way that can't be summarized by a consultant, or a graphic, or a PowerPoint presentation.

Enter that in your SAP system.

(Photo by fuzzcat via flickr)

, , , ,

Monday, May 07, 2007

Private-label cellular service arrives

Have you ever wanted your company's name on a cellphone service? For many clubs, charitable causes, etc., mobile service, used daily by nearly everyone, is a highly attractive product to offer to their members.

Today's Wall Street Journal discusses this market (free link), focusing on Sonopia, one of the companies providing a platform for clubs to resell mobile service.

The concept isn't brand new. Working Assets, a progressive political group, has been offering long distance service for nearly two decades and wireless since 2000. It recently announced that it is providing the platform for Planned Parenthood to offer its own branded mobile service. But Sonopia's recent launch has been the most visible to date.

The affinity group's value proposition to its members is as follows: cellphone service is a commodity, and if you have to buy a commodity somewhere, you might as well buy it from a group you care about (us), and channel some of the money (around 5%) our way.

More than this, though, the organizations feel they can deepen connections with their communities, both by having a logo on a product used daily and by having the ability to communicate with their constituents in a real-time, always-on manner.

But no one wants to do it at a loss, and even if cellphone service is a commodity, Verizon, Sonopia and the affinity group all want their piece of the pie. The question then is: will there be enough money to go around? And how many people will give up their Cingular family plan for a Yoga phone?

Time will tell whether private-label mobile phones are a long-term success, or merely a passing fad.

, , , , ,

Friday, May 04, 2007

What in hell is the Electron Economy?

I recently discovered an epic series of posts from Michael Hoexter, author of the Green Thoughts blog, on the Electron Economy. What is that? It's a point of view on sustainable energy use that focuses on relying more on electricity as opposed to relying on point of use fuels (petroleum, biodiesel, ethanol, hydrogen, etc.), emphasizing "the desirability of building out the electricity-based energy system as a means of harnessing most renewable and carbon-neutral forms of energy."

Here's Hoexter's thesis in brief:


Electricity generation, efficient forms of electric storage (electrochemical batteries and beyond), and electric motors, powered by renewable energy flows, should become even more central in our energy economy, much more important in the short and intermediate term than more celebrated biofuels or hydrogen fuel cells.

Hoexter has written an exhaustive document covering the past, present and potential future of electric power and its uses, makes a persuasive case, including statistics, that electricity is the nearest, best option for sustainable power--including for heating and transportation, two areas of limited electricity use today. (He points out that electric motors convert 85-90% of received energy into kinetic energy, while gasoline engines convert just 15-25%.) Add to that a pervasive distribution network (which have yet to develop for new fuels), and electricity may be where we should focus our R&D efforts, rather than switchgrass.

Here are Hoexter's posts:

Part 1
Part 2
Part 3

And if you have more time, here is the original source of the "electron economy" concept--a paper by Dr. Ulf Bossel of the European Fuel Cell Forum.

On the same subject, "Science Friday" from National Public Radio several weeks ago presented an interesting segment on advanced fuel technology in automobiles (download an mp3 of the broadcast here). It included an advocate for plug-in hybrids (Sherry Boschert, the author of "Plug-In Hybrids: The Cars That Will Recharge America"), whose arguments were more compelling to me after reading Hoexter's introduction.

Hey Toyota, when's your plug-in hybrid going to be ready?

(Thanks to my friends at Futurelab for alerting me to Michael Hoextler's work.)

(Lead photo by clix via stock.xchng)

, ,

Thursday, May 03, 2007

Dunkin' Donuts searches for new tribe members

Back in our single days, my friend Tom & I would go to Tia's on the waterfront in Boston for happy hour. One time, we began chatting with a certain girl there. We asked her what she did. She said, "I work for Dunkin' Donuts. I'm the product manager for donuts." We said, "Oh boy, that seems like the best job ever." And she said, "No it's not. The best job is to be the product manager for coffee. Do you know what the margin on a cup of coffee is?"

I recalled this story when I read today's Wall Street Journal article on Dunkin' Donuts and its expansion strategy. In new markets, Dunkin' has an easy time selling its baked products, but not as easy a time inserting itself into people's coffee habits. And, as the product manager we met told us, coffee is where the profits are.

To improve their chances, Dunkin' has profiled their typical customer--part of the Dunkin' "tribe." They are more down-to-earth (read: less pretentious) than Starbucks customers. (The company calculates that one-third of the country fits the profile.)

So you probably won't be able to get your double-caf no-whip caramel macchiato at Dunkin' Donuts. But you will be able to get a large coffee approximately the size of a Slurpee. Sometimes, that's all you need.

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox

Photo (c) Dunkin' Donuts. Used with permission.

, ,

Wednesday, May 02, 2007

Networking: burden or pleasure? It depends on how you approach it

Author Barbara Ehrenreich writes about personal networking in the latest issue of Forbes magazine (link--free with registration). She comes to the completely unsurprising conclusion that for most people networking is difficult and unpleasant.

She reveals the feelings of job-seekers (including herself, in another undercover escapade to gather material for a book) urged by life coaches to network, network, network. She cringes as she reads airport-bookstore-bestselling author Jeffrey Gitomer's advice to spend as little time as possible with each new acquaintance, the better to make more overall contacts. The way Ehrenreich describes it, networking is a predatory, utterly-calculated activity replete with victims and victimizers.

All of which misses the point. Of course, networking that is done purely for personal gain, where scores are kept, and especially when one is needy, can be pure agony for all involved. But that's not proper networking. (If it were, could it possibly have persisted?)

In the "Tao te Ching," Lao Tzu said, "Act before there is a problem. Bring order before there is disorder," and so it is with networking. If you begin network-building the day after you're laid off, you will find it a hard road indeed. When should you start? How about today?

At any rate, your "network" is a fancy term for your friends, relatives and acquaintances. Keith Ferrazzi, in his excellent book "Never Eat Alone," makes the point that talking about work with people we know is perfectly natural, and that keeping in touch with people, when you don't have an agenda, truly care about them, and are curious about them is one of the pleasures of life. [Ferrazzi's goal for new contacts made at an event: one. Have a nice day, Gitomer.]

In that context, when you know and touch enough people, they know what you do, and they are up to date with your situation. From that, opportunities will arise. And that's the point of networking.

(Thanks to the Wall Street Journal's Informed Reader blog for the tip.)

(Photo: bonsai tree by ired via stock.xchng)

, ,

Tuesday, May 01, 2007

Stop searching for influentials to infect with your message

Viral marketing is the 21st century version of the search for the Holy Grail--deeply desired and rarely attained. Why are campaigns that "tip" into mass acceptance from a small initial base so rare? Perhaps, as David Weinberger writes,

Insofar as it's about communicating a message, it's still alienating. As Doc said succinctly so many years ago, "There's no market for messages."
Thankfully, marketers have a less-sexy but more effective method of reaching their audiences--what Duncan Watts and Jonah Peretti in the May Harvard Business Review (free link) call "big-seed marketing."

Watts (who was responsible for one of the Top 5 Breakthrough Ideas reviewed in a prior post...as was Weinberger) and Peretti urge marketers to abandon the idea of finding the core group of influencers and creating a message so compelling that they can't help but share it with three friends, and so on and so on.

Instead, create an ad that's easily resent (using technology such as ForwardTrack) to a large number of people--the big seed--and let those who are interested send it along. Rather than an ever-increasing viral epidemic, you get an advertisement that lives for a while until it slowly peters out. With a large enough "seed," the results are significant.

The Oxygen network used such a method to promote a fundraiser for Hurricane Katrina victims, and found that 7,000 messages sent ended up reaching more than 20,000 readers.

So stop searching for influentials and send your message widely. Let the influentials select themselves.

(Photo by Accidental Angel via flickr)

, , ,