Monday, April 30, 2007

Making and obtaining effective promises--it's important and rare

OK, it's taken me an entire month, and my next issue of the Harvard Business Review is already in my mailbox, but I've finally absorbed the lessons in April's article entitled "Promise-Based Management: The Essence of Execution" (free link) by Donald Sull of the London Business School and Charles Spinosa of Vision Consulting.

The article contains straightforward advice on the importance of commitments to conducting business, as well as the poor way commitments are typically negotiated, with the expected result--nothing happens and negative surprises abound.

(Ever experience that at your workplace?)

By the way, straightforward doesn't mean simple to do. And that's the beauty of the article and why it's not something that sinks in over a quick read. Making and keeping (as well as obtaining) quality promises is very difficult, and poorly done at nearly all organizations.

And important too. With job specialization and matrix management, and especially today's alliance-based business environment, the potency of direct authority has waned. To get many things done at companies today, you need someone to agree to help you.

Sull and Spinosa give concrete examples of companies that use promises effectively. They also list five attributes of workable commitments:

  1. Public--good promises are shared outside the requester and provider
  2. Active--they are negotiated, but not part of prolonged debates (best quote: "Conversations should comprise offers, counteroffers, commitments and refusals rather than endless assertions about the state of nature")
  3. Voluntary--people who promise under duress don't feel obligated to deliver
  4. Explicit--commitments are clearly described and progress tracked
  5. Mission-based--requests are put in the context of strategy and objectives, so that providers know why the request matters
(Photo by pixelstar via stock.xchng)

, , ,

Friday, April 27, 2007

Motorola changed CEOs, but its culture lives on

Motorola is in trouble again. Despite forcing out the founding Galvin family and bringing in a highly-regarded outsider, Ed Zander, Motorola finds itself where it's been numerous times in its history--suffering because it couldn't follow up a hit product. In this case, where to go after the RAZR?

In a front-page article in today's Wall Street Journal (link - $$), writers Christopher Rhoads and Li Yuan review what got Motorola into its latest crisis--and find that it's a movie that Motorola-watchers have seen before. Rhoads and Yuan write:

As the Razr grew hot, some former designers and engineers say Motorola repeated mistakes it had made a decade earlier with another big hit, the compact flip-top phone known as the StarTAC. That phone was a huge seller, but it also was an analog phone, and its popularity blinded the company to an industry shift to digital technology. Similarly, while Motorola was selling countless Razrs, competitors were hard at work on more sophisticated products for 3G networks.

Zander was brought in to change "a culture he saw as inward and bureaucratic," yet he encountered a power struggle between the handset division president and an underling right away and seemed unable to defuse it. A year later, the division president left and his rival, Ron Garriques, replaced him. Garriques scrapped much of the ongoing development work his predecessor had authorized, and started afresh. Whatever the personal, business or technical reasons for the change, it had a nasty side effect--Motorola fell dangerously behind in developing 3G-capable handsets.

And now Zander is on the ropes, fighting for survival. Whether he stays or goes, the CEO of Motorola will have to confront how to harness its technical brilliance in service of great products that customers need, instead of ones that executives favor.

, , ,

Wednesday, April 25, 2007

What is equity?

An economist would say that it's discounted value of future cash flows. That's not a very useful definition, especially for those of us whose businesses are made up of largely intangible assets.

To me, as you're building a business, you've got revenue, you've got expenses. Hopefully the former is greater than the latter. And then you've got this other thing. As you work--performing projects, establishing relationships, selling business, getting references, hiring employees, building a brand--an almost imperceptible momentum grows and accrues over time.

You get bigger. You get better. People know your business. Customers sign up again and again. Someday, that will be worth something and people will offer to pay you for that.

That's equity.

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox

(Picture from sammi babe via stock.xchng)

,

How much is that mana in the window?

The very cool Hobby Princess blog tells us that when we buy a rare item, we're not buying the thing, we're buying its mana.

Tuesday, April 24, 2007

Email marketing--a second try

(For those entering our story in the middle, our hero had distributed his first email marketing newsletter in January, all by hand. It took three days of labor and caused him to swear revenge on his ISP. Click here to get the gory details. Somehow, it was a beneficial exercise, but there had to be a better, more effective way.)

It was now April, and time for the second quarterly newsletter. After checking out a bunch of email marketing service companies (there are lots of them--you can see them referenced at the bottom of virtually every email newsletter you receive), I signed up with Listrak.

The experience was light-years different. The service easily imported my two contact lists and eliminated duplicate addresses. It had an easy interface for me to load and edit my newsletter. I could send the newsletter to different test email addresses and see how it looked on Outlook, Internet Explorer, Firefox, etc. And with one click I could schedule the delivery of the newsletter at any time.

And it went out, last Thursday.

The results: 60% more newsletters delivered. 250+ bad email addresses identified. Clear traceability of who opened and read the newsletter. Tracking of each click on the newsletter. Oh, and about 80% less time spent on the process.

DISCLOSURE: Listrak's Director of Marketing is a former colleague of mine. She's written a lot of useful white papers on email marketing that you might want to read.

, ,

Email marketing--how NOT to do it

Have you ever created an email newsletter?

Ever read one?

I thought so. Few people who read email newsletters see what's going on behind them. I was part of that group till recently.

In January, I created and distributed my first email newsletter, completely manually. It was agonizing. First of all, my ISP treated me like a spammer by throttling the number of addressees I could have in any single send (despite the fact that I pay them every month for the privilege of having email accounts and a web site--how many spammers pay for their email accounts?). Furthermore, I had to let an hour or more pass before sending the next email (thanks, Yahoo!). It took the better part of three days to get the newsletter out.

And then, like all informal email, it was very difficult to see whether anyone was reading. I could make some indirect assessments of click rates, but that was all.

Finally, more than a few recipients generously responded with, "Hey, you should use an email marketing service. It will be much easier on you, and on us."

Despite all the hassles, the first newsletter brought tremendous benefits. I reconnected with several dozen former associates, spurred a bunch of new consulting opportunities, and began the process of cleansing my contact list (by fixing or deleting email addresses that were tagged as undeliverable).

Come April, it was time to do it again.

What happened? You'll have to wait till tomorrow.

, ,

Monday, April 23, 2007

The Utopian Company

Having worked for a number of companies and been dissatisfied in one way or another with how each of them is organized, I've always been fascinated with the idea that there is a way to construct a business organization for the benefit of all employees, as well as ownership.

So, I've devoured articles on SAS Institute and Peoplesoft (remember them?), two benevolent dictatorships, and SAIC, the employee-owned company.

And in today's Wall Street Journal, we read about Ternary, a small software developer that runs its business as a democracy. One, in fact, that requires unanimous consent to ratify decisions.

No kidding.

Before you go trying to implement the Ternary model at your company, be advised that they have only thirteen employees and once spent two days trying to agree on a mission statement.

Yet, despite the tendency to joke about approaches like Ternary's, there is something about trying to create a better organization that I, for one, find very appealing. Why?

The Journal says this:

Advocates say such systems appeal to workers, particularly younger ones, searching for careers with meaning. "Everyone wants to be a somebody," says Traci Fenton, founder of WorldBlu Inc., a Washington organization that promotes workplace democracy.
(UPDATE: Here is the WorldBlu list of most democratic workplaces.)

(Photo by winterling)

, ,

Friday, April 20, 2007

Does the record industry fix prices? The Economist thinks not

Let's talk about price-fixing, shall we? The Economist reported in a recent issue that the European Commission was re-opening its investigation into the merger that created recorded-music titan SonyBMG.

Says the Economist, "At issue is whether the four majors together might now reach an unspoken understanding about prices."

It's clear that CD suggested retail prices--it's clearly illegal for manufacturers to coerce an actual retail price from a retailer--are highly standardized. The actual retail prices, however, differ substantially based on the outlet (the latest Rascal Flatts CD at Wal-Mart costs far less than it does at Joe Nardone's Gallery of Sound).

The Commission is not concerned about retail prices; instead they are looking at whether wholesale prices--the prices that retailers pay to the record companies for their stock--are coordinated.

Here's why such coordination is virtually impossible. The power in retailing has shifted dramatically from manufacturer to retailer in the last twenty years (the recent book "Private Label Strategy" does a good job of explaining this shift). No record company dictates to Wal-Mart how much they must pay for CDs. Ditto Amazon and Target. So such collusion, difficult as it is to coordinate between the four companies, would fall apart anyway once they tried to enforce it with their retail customers.

So we can all breathe a sigh of relief about that and go back to illegally downloading our music over peer-to-peer networks. (Just kidding!)

(Pictured: the new album from Son Volt, distributed by SonyBMG)

, , , ,

Thursday, April 19, 2007

More Most Significant Change (MSC) - how to use for business?

In an earlier post, I introduced the concept of Most Significant Change, a monitoring and evaluation technique that was developed for international aid programs. In short, MSC gathers stories and anecdotes on the impact a program has made for its clients, then sorts and selects them through several levels until a single story is selected that represents the most significant change brought on by that program.

So, in business, how would you use it? Let's take the example of the new performance evaluation program that we discussed in the earlier post. Let's say that the company used MSC to monitor this program. HR folks at each division collect stories, then via dialogue they select the most significant in their division; it's passed up the chain, and a further selection is done, and so on, until the executive team selects one story most significant for the whole program. In our example, here's the story they chose:

The most significant change for me, I guess, is that my boss never used to talk to me about performance until review time. Then, you know, I was usually in for a surprise-good or bad. Between reviews, nothing. So, then, after the new system was put in place, it took a few weeks, but all of a sudden she started talking to me about how I was doing as part of our regular one-on-one meeting. Things I was doing well, other things I should do differently. So I could fix what I was doing right away--and not get slammed in a review months later. More than that, a month or so after the program started, she came up to me and said, "Jim, this project plan you sent me to approve, it looks OK, but when you do your project plans, it would be more effective if you put the name of the responsible person alongside each task. That way, if there's a schedule slip, I know who I might need to follow up with." That's a pretty big change compared to what had happened before.

What does this story say about the program? It says that, at least in one case, it spurred a manager to provide feedback on a timely basis. (Disclosure: like the vast majority of technology managers, I am not very good at this aspect of personnel management.)

The story doesn't say that the program spurred this improvement for every manager--or even more than one. However, its selection as the most significant story tells everyone that this is the kind of behavior that the program was intended to foster. Which has three big benefits:

  1. Clear communication - one very important program outcome is communicated to everyone in a very tangible, usable way.
  2. Enables action - Management can now monitor whether this desirable change is a trend or an isolated case, and intervene accordingly.
  3. "More like this" - The people who select the most significant stories are cued to look for stories like this as they do their selections.
And it's repeated on a regular basis, say every quarter or half-year. Over time, it shapes the organization's view of the project and its objectives, far better than a bland statement ("We intend to improve the effectiveness of management in the areas of personnel appraisal and feedback, blah blah blah"). And it brings the management teams together regularly for intense dialogue about important issues, and causes them to make a joint decision (which is rare for lots of management teams).

Pretty useful, eh?

(Illustration from the MSC Guide by Rick Davies and Jess Dart (c) 2004, via Inforesources.)

Wednesday, April 18, 2007

The power of business relationships: an example

During my junior year in college (1983), I applied for a summer internship at IBM. Like more than 90% of the people who applied, I was turned down via form letter. When I told my dad this, he said, you know--I know somebody who might be able to help. My dad was a car salesman and one of his customers happened to be a Human Resources executive at IBM. A week later I had a phone interview, & a week after that I had a job offer. It might've changed the course of my career, & I have networking to thank for that.

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox

, ,

Tuesday, April 17, 2007

Your leader expects you to stay current

I love the article by Larry Bossidy (author of Execution) in this month's Harvard Business Review, although I do detect an obsession with command-and-control language by former Jack Welch lieutenants in the way they speak and write about business. (For example, Bob Nardelli and Steve Bennett, in addition to Bossidy.)

As you'd guess, the article is called, "What Your Leader Expects Of You."

But I digress. In spite of its military crispness and the frequent use of "I" as a synonym for the business itself, it is an excellent article. Here's the section I like best:

Stay current. There's nothing more depressing than sitting in a business meeting with people who don't know what's going on in the world. I expect people to read, to watch the news - not just because it makes them more interesting but because what happens in the world affects what happens to us, to our marketplace, and to out competition.

About fifteen years ago, I was a product manager, and I found that I kept being invited to meetings even though I wasn't formally connected to the meeting's subject matter at all. After I turned down several invitations, I learned that people were inviting me because I brought a provocative point of view and wasn't afraid to talk. Soon after this, one manager came to me and said the following,

"You're so knowledgeable about the industry and what's going on. Where do you learn all this stuff?"

"The Wall Street Journal and industry publications, for the most part. Sometimes Business Week and the Harvard Business Review. They're in the company library."

"That's great. Would you be willing to sit down with our group once a week and give us an overview of important things we should know?"

I was speechless for a couple of moments. "Are you saying you'd like me to do the group's reading for them?" I said finally. "I'm sorry, but I don't have the time or the desire to do that."

(Picture by a_kartha via stock.xchng)

, , ,

P.S. To the title of Bossidy's book--isn't that another great military word? And it reminds me of an anecdote--a great old football coach named John McKay was asked, after a particularly poor performance, by his team, "What do you think about your team's execution?"

"I think it's a good idea," replied Coach McKay.

Monday, April 16, 2007

Pulitzer committee takes a cue from Shop Talk

James Bandler, Charles Forelle and Mark Maremont's articles on stock option backdating today were awarded the Pulitzer Prize for Public Service. We had this figured out in December.

UPDATE (23 Apr 2007): Here is a complete free archive of the Journal's options backdating articles.

Saturday, April 14, 2007

Google works in mysterious ways


The traffic on this site spiked yesterday--up about four-fold from the average of the rest of the week. Why? Blame Google Images.

Last November I posted on why the characters on "Lost" were like the management of a dysfunctional company. To illustrate the post, I found (on Google Images, of course) a promotional picture that had been used by a South Korean television network. I pasted it into the post, and that was that.

After the first of the year, when new episodes of "Lost" began again, I started seeing traffic spikes from time to time based on people searching for "Lost" images on Google.

And yesterday, it happened again. I went to Google Images, typed "Lost." And saw my blog post as the #1 result. (Why my picture instead of the original from South Korea? Or any other picture, for that matter?) People from Turkey, the UK, the US, Japan, Saudi Arabia, Canada, Austria and many others, all checking out that picture.

Some even spent time reading the content.

The internet can be a really random place sometimes.

(Of course, I couldn't resist posting the picture again.)
UPDATE: April 15. Traffic is back to normal. Ran the Google Images search again. My post is nowhere to be found...

Friday, April 13, 2007

An anecdote on the power of business narrative analysis

I had lunch with a former colleague yesterday, whom I hadn't seen in ten years. She related to me this story:

Last year we had a pilot of a new performance management system for our employees. The trial group was 4000 people. We had spent a lot of time on the pilot and gathered a lot of data. At the end of the trial, the VP of Human Resources printed out all the comments that had been received on the survey forms. He took them home one night and read every single one. Then he came in the next day and said, "We can't roll this system out." And that was it. The trial was very expensive. We'd gathered lots of data, lots of numbers, but the final determinant was what he read in those comments.


I had been talking to my friend about collecting and analyzing business narrative to assess organizational change using Anecdote's methods. I told her, "He didn't use a system, and comments aren't necessarily stories. But, in essence, your VP was using the narrative technique."

Thursday, April 12, 2007

What in hell is Most Significant Change?

Let's first pose a problem. You've put in place a new performance evaluation system and spent a year conducting reviews using it.

How's it working out for you?

Your program will have target objectives like improved employee satisfaction, perhaps, or increased personnel retention. But the first indicator is difficult to baseline and measure, and the second requires a long time to discern a change.

Complex initiatives...vague indicators of success...the hunger to know whether something costly and labor-intensive was worthwhile.

International aid programs face this problem every day, and from that domain has emerged a new method for monitoring these types of programs.

It's called Most Significant Change. (Here's the official guide, written by Rick Davies, the creator of the approach, and Jess Dart.) At its most basic, this deceptively simple approach asks field workers (or first-line managers in the business context) to elicit anecdotes from the people affected, focusing on what most significant change has occurred as the result of the initiative, and why they think that change occurred. These dozens or hundreds of stories are passed up the chain and winnowed down to the most significant, as determined by each management layer, until finally one story is selected.

It's not numbers, or graphs, or ROIs. It's a story, with an explanation, and behind it a collection of other significant stories. A story that describes a real experience, reviewed, defended, and selected by the people charged with the success of the program.

Why can this monitoring method work for programs like our performance evaluation system? I'll discuss that in another post.

Wednesday, April 11, 2007

Billionaire's brilliant quote of the week (last week's edition)

From Warren Buffett, as paraphrased by Prof. Jeremy Siegel (thanks to Greg Mankiw for pointing it out):

[Buffett] wisely counsels that anything that happens to your finances is secondary to the important things in life – picking a suitable and compatible mate, developing a relationship with your children, and doing something that you enjoy.

I'm very fortunate on the first two points--I think I've got them licked--and working hard on #3.

Billionaire's brilliant quote of the week

From John W. Kluge, benefactor of the Kluge Scholars Program at Columbia College, quoted in today's New York Times:

I'd rather by far invest in people than buildings.


Tuesday, April 10, 2007

Dream becomes reality--the anything maker

When I was a kid I had a recurring dream that I had a special machine. I loaded plastic pellets into the machine, then if I designed something on paper & fed it into the machine, it would create what I had imagined.

Now I find out that such a machine exists. See the following link. (Thanks Ilya Vedrashko for pointing it out.)

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox

, , ,

Thursday, April 05, 2007

Prospecting yields are low--get used to it

I've recently talked to a couple of self-employed folks who came out of corporate staff jobs. Their unanimous opinion: marketing is a pain in the neck!

When I probed a bit, I found their frustration centered on the low conversion of prospects to sales. And on further probing, it became clear that their expectations for closing rates were much too high. "I meet someone, or get a referral, I give them a proposal. How come they don't buy?"

Buyers need to be ready, willing and able to purchase your product or service. Many of the prospects you encounter are: unqualified, not interested, not ready, not able to make purchases, distracted, etc. Depending on your business, 80%/90%/95% of the leads you get won't pan out, even if you do a good job selling.

The key is to find the nuggets of gold in your prospect list as quickly as possible, and don't waste time on the others (though you want to keep their information handy for future marketing--so that when they are ready, willing, and able, you are top of mind for them).

And that implies you must focus on lead generation. Frustration at conversion yields often truly means you didn't get enough prospects into the top of the funnel to have an adequate level of closed business out the other end.

So stop complaining, and start prospecting.

, , ,

Wednesday, April 04, 2007

Putting ideas into language - and sharing them - makes them come alive

Ever heard someone say, "I have a book all figured out--I just have to put it on paper"? Millions of us are like that. The biggest delusion in this statement is that something in one's head exists for anyone but the thinker. It doesn't.

Which brings me to a great article in this month's Harvard Business Review (link - $) from Steelcase CEO James Hackett on using ideas from complexity theory to enhance the front end of the company's product development and launch process. (Worry not; it's a very practical article.)

Hackett makes a compelling case for taking a beginner's mindset, thinking deeply, and learning before starting implementation of a new product idea. He shows how this worked for Steelcase entering the market for clinical workstations. But this small quote also caught my eye.

Throughout [the thinking phase,] they document the depth and breadth of their research to assemble information into a sensible whole. Documentation is critical; the kinesthetic work cements their thinking [emphasis mine] and creates tangible evidence of their efforts....

The same concept was part of the Gap International and Anecdote Narrative in Business (which also touched on complexity theory) workshops I recently attended.

In summary: putting ideas into language forces your brain to organize and make sense of them; sharing the ideas commits yourself to them and allows others to commit as well.

[It's one of the uses I find for this activity of blogging.]

(Photo from andybahn via stock.xchng)

Monday, April 02, 2007

CEOs like stories

Conventional wisdom tells us that CEOs are bottom-line oriented. If you can't reduce it to numbers for them, it doesn't exist. I disagree with that characterization. I believe that CEOs hunger for non-quantitative information, but typical means of communication are too boring, time-consuming and contextless to provide them much value.

So what works? Stories. (Don't laugh--this is why I didn't post this yesterday, on April Fools' Day.) Stories are brief, detailed, vivid and provide context. Imagine this conversation:

CEO: We had to slam the Heltech merger in. What's the impact been on morale?

Division VP: It's been a bit of a struggle. There have been issues.

CEO: Such as?

Division VP: Well, for instance, there was the customer who got called on by two salespeople, one Heltech and one of our guys, and chewed out our guy for not being coordinated. He's our best sales guy, and got really upset by that.

CEO: Anything else?

Division VP: The websites got combined right away, but not the call centers, so a Heltech center started getting calls for our old products, and couldn't help, and there weren't good handoff procedures yet. So I got a bunch of angry customer calls. One said she was going to tell her CIO to start an RFP process to find a replacement. I think I got her calmed down, but we'll see.

CEO: OK, I get it. What do you think we need to do at this point?

Total elapsed time: less than 2 minutes. Information conveyed: terabytes. In these two brief stories, the CEO has gotten the message that they need to quickly fix the remaining integration issues. Think a stack of PowerPoint slides could've done that?

(Photo from scyza via stock.xchng)

Sunday, April 01, 2007

Feeling constrained is a great inspiration to innovate

'Presentation Zen had another great, novelistic post stating that complaining about constraints in product design is completely misguided—in fact, dealing creatively with severe constraints is the essence of good design.

Then, the New York Times profiled 19-year-old basketball player Greg Oden, variously called the next Bill Russell or Tim Duncan (either is a great compliment, but I'd take Russell), and his switch to shooting left-handed after a serious injury and surgery to his right wrist. As a result, now that his right wrist is healed, he's a much more valuable player than he would have been if he hadn't been required to learn to use his left hand.

I'm working to create something within significant constraints. I've been playing with the Spin-my-Blog service (which allows me to talk for up to a minute and then send the transcription directly to my blog) for some weeks, and I've created a new form that will use the capabilities of the system.

Postlets: very short, conversational posts with limited (preferably no) editing, focusing on a brief business-related anecdote, hopefully funny. I'll load them up whenever they pop into my head.

Saturday's post is an example of the postlet form. Perhaps it adds a bit of freshness or change of pace to the normal blogging stuff. Let me know what you think.

, , , ,

Saturday, March 31, 2007

Don' forget to love your own company's brands

I had a web hit from someone at Microsoft today, and what I thought was funny was that the searcher used Google.com. That reminded me of a story.

Way back I got my dream summer job, an internship at IBM, and my first day in the office my boss asked me to make a copy of a bunch of documents, so I went to one of the other people in my office and I said, "Hey, can you tell me where the Xerox machine is?" He responded, "We make copiers here."

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox


,

Wednesday, March 28, 2007

Clean out those old products from the cupboard

This month's PDMA Visions magazine, in an article by Leland Shaeffer, Rafael Lopes and Eric Rose, takes up a little-known part of the product manager's job: that of retiring old products.

It's a job that people avoid. As a result, the article states, many companies suffer because they don't truly understand the downside of carrying too many obsolete products.

In many cases, companies mistake revenue for profit. Products that still have a customer base are assumed to be profitable, especially since any development cost was long-ago amortized.

In fact, write the authors, because they've lost scale and scope, old products can easily lose money on a direct-cost basis. Add to this the opportunity cost due to the time and energy these products take up throughout the organization, and hanging onto too many old dogs can significantly affect company profitability.

Getting rid of obsolete products is difficult. There are customers to migrate or fire, distributors to negotiate with, and generally a lack of standards around product retirement.

One interesting suggestion from the authors: plan for product obsolescence in the initial product plan (akin to including terms for ending a partnership in the initial partnership agreement).

Another: set aside "retirement funds" to allow product managers to cover shutdown costs for obsolete products--and thereby remove another reason for old products to persist: plain old inertia.

(Photo from zdeso via stock.xchng)

Tuesday, March 27, 2007

Don't kick the bucket: it's got your unused cellphone minutes in it

Finishing today's roundup with breaking news from the Wall Street Journal (link): the word bucket has become the business world's favorite metaphor. A delightful front-page article describes how bucket has supplanted other terms like silo (missile connotation = bad) and basket (too feminine) as a way to express organization or sorting of people, financial figures or other miscellany.

(The Journal seemed to run more of this type of story in the past. Am I the only one who thinks its recent makeover reduced its sense of humor as well as the size of the paper?)

One consultant is asked whether European cellphone companies will adopt the term to describe allotments of minutes included in a monthly plan, as American companies already do. “'They will adopt bucket,' he says. 'That is my strong feeling.'”

, , , ,

Think business as usual doesn't cost you money? Check out Parker Hannifin

If you thought cost-plus pricing went out with the Reagan administration, read today's front page Wall Street Journal article on Parker Hannifin Corporation and the efforts by its CEO to overhaul its decades-old pricing approach.

Parker's managers priced their 800,000 products using roughly the same formula: cost plus 35%, whether the product was a commodity or a one-of-a-kind.

According to consultant Tom Nagle (disclosure: my old pricing professor), 60% of industrial companies still price in this manner. Yikes!

With the help of outside consultants (and an iron-willed CEO moving aside internal objections), Parker sorted its products into five buckets from commodity through most differentiated, and raised prices on most. Some commodity products saw their prices lowered.

Possibly the most difficult task was to push the price increases though their distributors and customers objections. But the result was a $200 million increase in operating income and a return on invested capital rising from 7% to 21%.

The lesson for businesses is to look at pricing regularly. Don't let your pricing or your pricing model get stale. And don't be afraid of raising prices when you find a product priced too low. (Perhaps try some deliberate mistakes by raising prices on a small subset of products and see what happens.) The results can be astounding.

, , ,

Take a vacation, why don't you?

Regular readers of this blog may already realize that I'm hung up on sleep, or lack thereof (see here). Perhaps it's because, with children just having emerged from the wake-several-times-a-night phase, I'm on a first-name basis with sleep deprivation. It also may be evidence of a career-long struggle to find balance in a culture that celebrates and honors workaholism and sleep avoidance.

At any rate, more good news for people who just want a rest arrived today. The New York Times's Frequent Flier column profiled consultant Mark Rosekind of Alertness Solutions , a former director of NASA's fatigue countermeasures program (now that's a job title). His assertion? In addition to getting more sleep, you also need a vacation. Says Rosekind:

I just completed a study for Air New Zealand that suggests that if people actually took their allotted vacation time, they could improve their performance by more than 80 percent.
If you still don't get the message, Rosekind includes a truly frightening anecdote about a TV reporter who, apparently out of story ideas, went without sleep for three days. What she experienced the last day will make you want to take a nap straightaway.

, , ,

Monday, March 26, 2007

The man who harnessed the power of dialogue

Dr. Milton Wexler died earlier this month at age 98. Dr. Wexler was a sucessful Hollywood psychotherapist who co-wrote the screenplays for the films "The Man Who Loved Women" and "That's Life!" with the director Blake Edwards. But those factoids were not what interested me when I read his obituary in last Saturday's New York Times.

Dr. Wexler devised a new technique to spur progress on the research of Huntington's Disease, a terrifying genetic disorder that claimed the life of his first wife. (Here's a recent story about Huntington's.) The Times obit stated:

He formed the Hereditary Disease Foundation to gather young scientists from different disciplines and institutions for freewheeling talks about Huntington’s as well as to sponsor research....

His strategy was one he developed for group therapy among creative people: no-holds-barred discussion toward a common purpose in a nonthreatening climate.

The research that emerged “changed everything in the world of genetic disease,” Dr. Housman said, adding that many influential scientists had not expected so much progress for 100 years.

What can a psychotherapist--not a medical researcher--do to attack the disease that took his wife and threatened his children? One would imagine that Dr. Wexler would feel powerless. Instead, he harnessed the power of dialogue and spearheaded significant advances against the disease.

It might not be a stretch to call the Hereditary Disease Foundation the world's first open source project. In that, Dr. Wexler was twenty years ahead of his time.

, , , ,

Friday, March 23, 2007

Ask more of, and raise rewards for, employee idea-generators

Innovation via employee-generated ideas fails at most companies. Employees generate a number of ill-thought-through concepts that management, to its embarrassment, must quickly discard. "Winners" get a handshake, a plaque, perhaps a $100 check. Eventually comes a suspension, termination or petering out of the idea-generation initiative, which then finds its way into the lore of company failures, never to be repeated.

I've seen that happen at more than one company. Gary Carini and Bill Townsend, writing in the April Harvard Business Review (free link through April 2007), suggest two fundamental changes in these programs: (1) require employees to flesh out their ideas and develop realistic business cases for them and (2) increase the rewards for those ideas that work to more than symbolic levels.

The authors write:

Companies that required employees to present business cases for their ideas and offered substantial rewards saw the number of workable ideas rise significantly...[increasing] in the 20% to 40% range.

They suggested rewards such as half the first year's savings for a cost-reduction idea. For one administrative assistant, that was worth $152,000. For that kind of potential reward, I'd put my thinking cap on, no matter what my job.

Thursday, March 22, 2007

Daimler pitches continued alliance after Chrysler sold

As discussed a few weeks ago when DaimlerChrysler first revealed the option to sell Chrysler to another investor, untangling the connections between the Mercedes and Chrysler operating units poses a challenge for buyer and seller. Perhaps to reassure investors, and get a better price for their asset, Daimler yesterday announced (as reported in the Wall Street Journal) that it would be willing to continue many aspects of the cooperation between Mercedes and Chrysler.

Daimler's offer of joint purchasing, component sharing, etc., after a divestment is more appealing to a private-equity buyer than another car company, which might have strategic and competitive reasons for limiting such sharing (as might Daimler).

Splitting operating siblings who are in the same business is the corporate equivalent of separating conjoined twins. After years of union, each has grown to rely on systems and processes provided by the other twin. When the units are separated, those systems must be recreated. Daimler's offer to continue important partnerships allows the weaker twin (i.e., Chrysler) to continue to benefit from the stronger twin's systems, as well as save expenses, even if they aren't formally connected anymore.

(Photo still from the movie "Stuck On You")

, , ,

Wednesday, March 21, 2007

On designing

Lots of talk this week about design, including Business Week writer Bruce Nussbaum's broadside on arrogant designers, and reaction here, here and here.

I am a rank amateur when it comes to the aesthetics of design. For example, my wife created the vision and look for our house's new addition, specifying materials, sizes, configurations; my biggest contribution was to appreciate the result.

With regards to technology products, I perhaps have more to offer. Aesthetics are a small (though significant) part of what constitutes design for tech products. A much larger component is answering this question:

What will the product do, and what will it not do?

The functions of traditional products (buildings, furniture, housewares) are typically constrained by tradition, physics and the properties of the materials used. Designers of high-tech products, especially those that are software-driven, face innumerable choices about what to include (a term has emerged describing a typical result: "software bloat"). The first personal computers sidestepped these decisions by providing platforms with little built into them (except a compiler--the message to users was, "use it for whatever you can build!"). Word processing programs, spreadsheets, Powerpoint, games, web browsers, anti-virus programs, e-mail programs, etc., followed.

Formerly lower-tech products like automobiles and airplanes now confront this scoping problem. BMW replaced radio knobs with iDrive, a function-stuffed, nearly unusable system. Delays in Airbus's A380 project stemmed not from issues with airworthiness, but from problems with the 300+ miles of electrical wiring.

iDrive and PCs demonstrate the biggest negative side effect of the urge to function-stuff. The more things a product can do, the harder it is for mere mortals to use. Consider the following question: if you have one PC in the house, in which room do you place it?

Apple's genius with the iPod, iMovie and other products was to design them to do less, to make them supremely usable (and good-looking) and of limited functionality. For them, the iPhone will pose a challenge: how to create something with as many uses as a Swiss Army knife but which doesn't baffle its buyers.

(Picture by Annette via stock.xchng)

, , ,

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

Computing pioneer dies at age 82

The man who led the creation of Fortran, the first successful high-level computing language, John W. Backus, died Saturday at age 82. According to this obituary in the New York Times, Mr. Backus grew tired of "hand-to-hand combat with the machine" via assembly language, and convinced his superiors at IBM to let his team create a new language that communicated with the computer at a higher level of abstraction; i.e. closer to the process of human thinking. The first Fortran compiler was completed in 1957, a year before the word "software" had even been coined.

The Times added:

Fortran was also extremely efficient, running as fast as programs painstakingly hand-coded by the programming elite, who worked in arcane machine languages. This was a feat considered impossible before Fortran. It was achieved by the masterful design of the Fortran compiler, a program that captures the human intent of a program and recasts it in a way that a computer can process.

People who once programmed in Fortran are getting older, and many have moved onto other professions, like marketing.

Rest in peace, Mr. Backus.

, , , ,

The value of B2B brands

Jon Miller of the Marketo blog has a very powerful post refuting some people's belief that B2B brands don't matter, and that investing in brand-building is a waste of money for B2B companies.

I'd go as far as to say that anyone who thinks that brands don't matter in business-to-business sales hasn't sold to many businesses. And certainly hasn't been involved in buying much for their companies.

In my experience, selling with a well-established brand behind me is much easier than selling an unknown brand. And buying a well-established brand conveys stability, longevity, predictability and a measure of security.

By way of the evidence of B2B brands' value, I'd point readers to the March Harvard Business Review, in which James Gregory of CoreBrand and Donald Sexton of Columbia University describe their method for calculating the brand equity of business-to-business companies. (A free copy is available by following this link.) Sexton and Gregory concluded there were significant deltas in brand equity between leading companies and lagging companies across many B2B industry groups. For instance, in the Office Equipment category, brand equity ranged from 18.37% of market cap (highest) to 4.26% of market cap (lowest).

If B2B brands are meaningless, how then to explain the differences in brand equity these statistics illustrate?

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox

Monday, March 19, 2007

Candor in business storytelling

It's called a "confidence" game, right? Why? Because you give me your confidence? No, because I give you mine. So what we have here, in addition to "Adventures in Human Misery," is a short course in psychology. - David Mamet, House of Games screenplay, p. 34

"House of Games" is one of my favorite movies, and these lines in particular, spoken by the con man Mike to the psychologist Dr. Margaret Ford, have stuck in my mind for years. I think they say something important about connecting with people.

Connecting with people is critical for selling. And one of the ways we connect with people is to tell them stories about ourselves. [And, no, I'm not trying to compare selling with a con game. Was it necessary to point that out?]

The theme here is candor and openness. I was at a business storytelling workshop recently, and the stories that were most effective (by acclamation of the attendees) were ones where the teller let down his/her guard, and revealed something personal. This is one of the reasons storytelling is more effective than reciting a list of benefits to a prospect. In addition to being interesting and easy to understand, it also helps create a personal bond with the prospect. It means that you may want, in your business storytelling, to reveal anxieties, fears and feelings.

In other words, to give the prospect your confidence.

(Photo still from the MGM DVD.)

Good service--a product's most lucrative feature?

Customer service is so often seen as a necessary evil, or, worse, the first place to cut costs, that it's easy for product managers to focus on other areas. But an article in the March Harvard Business Review makes it clear that good service creates shareholder value, and poor service destroys it.

The article (link - $$), by Christopher Hart of the Spire Group, points to a study from the University of Michigan, which created a hedge portfolio based on buying companies rated highly on the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI) and selling short those rated poorly on the ACSI, which tracks customers' perceptions of more than 200 companies.

Over a five-year period, the ACSI hedge portfolio grew 144.5%, while the S&P 500 grew 38.7%. (Here are some other comparisons of high ACSI and low ACSI companies.)

The article also shows evidence that service problems have a greater effect on customer's likelihood to recommend than the product problems that create the service calls in the first place.

So, think twice before you disable the "0" key on your IVR or send your contact center to Asia. If it doesn't make your customer service better, it's better not done at all.

Friday, March 16, 2007

Here's how I'm using Spin-my-Blog

For the last couple of weeks, I've been doing occasional posts using the Spin-my-Blog voice blogging service. What I've found to be the best approach is to use it as a place to post ideas. Things that I would otherwise write on a sticky note, instead, I speak into the phone. The system translates them to text and sends them directly to my blog listing as draft posts, where I can then edit them, expand them, add photos and tags and prepare them for publication.

It's highly convenient, saves typing time, and I don't lose any ideas (which, I suppose, is not always a good thing).

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox


, , , , ,

Thursday, March 15, 2007

Favorite non-business business blogs

Can blogs that aren't about business shed light on problems we businesspeople face every day? James March, the professor who taught us about foolishness, might say yes. Here are my favorites:

  1. Hobby Princess - all about handicrafts, yet sprinkling in lessons for those of us in business. Check out this post about how small can be better than big. Or this one about the conflicts between copyrights and open source.

  2. Greg Mankiw's Blog - economics brought to ground level by a Harvard professor. Ostensibly a tool for his introductory econ students, the blog takes on questions of government policies and looks at them with an economist's eye. Want to learn what Pigovian taxes are? Check here.

  3. David Report blog - on design of architecture, furniture, clothing. Beautiful pictures and some thought-provoking commentary about how design can improve or degrade our lives.

  4. Bill Walsh's Blogslot - the author, a copy editor for the Washington Post, regularly points out poor grammar and word choice in the nation's newspapers. The lessons for anyone who writes (i.e., all of us) are invaluable. Here's a simple take on an emerging problem in blog grammar.
, , , ,

Wednesday, March 14, 2007

Hershey: the end of an era approaches

There was a small item in the Wall Street Journal today mentioning that the Hershey Company, among others, might be interested in purchasing the confectionary business of Cadbury Schweppes. Perhaps you didn't notice that. But you don't live where I do.

Our house is a few miles from the self-proclaimed "sweetest place on Earth"--Hershey, Pennsylvania. Here, Hershey is more than a company, more even than a large local employer. It is the pre-eminent industrial symbol of the area. The Hershey name graces the town (the company came first), a gigantic amusement park close enough to the factory for guests to smell the cocoa, two hotels, a minor-league hockey team, several schools, and the largest teaching hospital within 100 miles. Main Street is called Chocolate Avenue.

It's quaint, really, and, like most things quaint, its days are numbered. The early warning sign occurred in 2002, when the company put itself up for sale. A huge local backlash rose up and quashed that idea. But the changes in the offing for Hershey were just beginning.

Last month, Hershey announced that it would reduce employment by 1500 people and open a large plant in Mexico. The Harrisburg Patriot-News reported that staff members had been told the toll could be 3000 workers. The catalog-fulfillment side of the business is being outsourced to Philadephia and Illinois.

And the purchase of a company like Cadbury wouldn't be just a purchase. Cadbury is larger than Hershey, and more global. Any such combination would mean more production shifting, right-sizing, and the like. There's no way Hershey would still be Hershey the way we know it here, today.

Someday, I'll tell my grandkids about the time we lived near a company town, and they will say to me in response, "What's that?"

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox


(Photo from the Hershey web site)

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

Web 2.0 - coming soon to your office desktop, or not?

A great post by corporate IT guru Andrew McAfee last week chastised FastForward conference attendees for their blind faith that Web 2.0 tools will gain widespread adoption in business. And it got me thinking about how companies and individuals use Web 2.0 tools differently. Here is one conclusion:


The great convenience and usefulness of Web 2.0 tools has spurred their rapid adoption by consumers (e.g., 50 million+ blogs, according to Technorati), while concerns over security and control of information have inhibited their adoption by corporations.

And that's much to the detriment of business. Collaboration is essential to any business. And with large businesses in particular, collaboration across distances and other boundaries (organizational, time, national, etc.) is mandatory. Yet IT departments don't know how to deal with some of the best tools--wikis, blogs, content tagging, social networks, etc.--that can benefit that collaboration.

Like individuals, businesses will have to give up some of their obsession with confidentiality and privacy in order to make use of these tools. The companies who figure out how to solve that equation first will have a great advantage. The rest will be wondering, five years from now, what happened.

, ,

Monday, March 12, 2007

PGA Tour has lost its sense...of branding

Sports marketing has been careening toward the cliff of excess for some time now (the wall-to-wall corporate sponsorship depicted in "Talladega Nights" was more verisimilitude than parody). But the recent revolving door of sponsor-named events in the US PGA golf tour is seriously damaging the history and heritage of US professional golf.

The latest example is something called the PODS Championship, held this past weekend in Florida. (PODS stands for Portable On-Demand Storage, in the form of a shipping container that this company drops in your front yard for you to fill with stuff, where it sits till your house project is done, much to the delight of your neighbors.)

The PODS Championship used to be the Chrysler Championship, and was held in the fall, not in early March. It's always been in the Tampa area, but you wouldn't know that from any of the communication surrounding the event. In fact, for all I knew (and I'm a golf fan!), this was a brand-spanking new event.

I could have said the same thing about the Wachovia Championship, the Fry's Electronics Open, the Buick Classic, the Buick Open or the Buick Invitational, not to mention the late, great 84 Lumber Classic. (Some of these were events with history, and some were new. See if you can guess which!)

What ever happened to the Westchester Classic, the Western Open, or the Firestone Tournament of Champions? At least AT&T was smart enough to retain part of the historical name of its tournament (the AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am).

Exclusive naming rights bring tens of millions of dollars yearly to the PGA Tour, helping purses to grow tenfold between 1986 and 2006, according to GolfWorld. But at some point they'll be ruing the day the good old Greater Hartford Open became the Travelers.

Friday, March 09, 2007

Yahoo-AT&T: an alliance under pressure

Nothing cures end of the week writer's block better than a front page Wall Street Journal article on one of my favorite subjects: alliances. Today's article about the shifts underway in the Yahoo-AT&T partnership contains lessons for any company in an alliance or contemplating one.

AT&T is seeking to renegotiate the terms of the alliance, under which it pays Yahoo a revenue share for each DSL customer it signs up via Yahoo, and funnels traffic to Yahoo services through its home page. Simply put, the world has changed since the original deal was signed in 2001, and so has the power dynamic in the alliance.

AT&T has made two gigantic acquisitions and now is a behemoth with 12 million broadband customers and a strong nationwide brand. Yahoo has fallen to number two in internet search and advertising to Google. Add the fact that Google is paying people for placement on computer screens and home pages, and Yahoo will have to take a serious haircut as the alliance is recast.

The lesson for those striking alliances--monitor changes in the landscape and be prepared to make adjustments (or have them thrust upon you) as your business and your partner's change. No good thing lasts forever.

(Update: in a tantalizing blog post, the Journal speculates that the endgame of this alliance could result in AT&T acquiring Yahoo.)

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox

Thursday, March 08, 2007

Cold calling with dignity (yours and the prospect's)

I had to do some cold calling today, so naturally I worked from Jeff Thull's script. It's simply the best approach I know to keep the dignity of the customer intact while you're interrupting them with an unsolicited pitch. And since I hate getting cold calls, when I do my own cold calling I try to keep that in mind. Here's Jeff's 20-second pitch, outlined nicely in his new book Exceptional Selling.

Convey professionalism by identifying yourself and your company straightaway. "I'm John Caddell with Caddell Insight Group." (Don't ask how they are doing today.)

Give the prospect an easy way out, and show respect for his/her intelligence by admitting that you don't know if they need or want what you're pitching (note: you should have done sufficient preparation and qualification to believe they very well might need your solution). "I'm not sure if it's appropriate we should be talking."

Show relevancy by connecting what you do to companies like the prospect's. "We work with companies like yours who are developing breakthrough technology products..."

Connect more deeply by referencing a generic problem they might be facing. "...and occasionally have difficulty getting their sales forces to embrace the new product."

Ask for permission to continue. "Do you have a moment to talk?"

There's lots more to the method, especially if they say, "Yes, I'd like to talk more." But you'll have to read the book for the rest.

Voice-to-Screen messaging - powered by SpinVox



, , ,

Wednesday, March 07, 2007

Public radio's Ira Glass on storytelling

Two of my favorite bloggers have posted on Ira Glass' (This American Life) videos on storytelling.

Shawn Callahan of Anecdote discusses the video here and connects it to the work his team does with businesses. (There are still a few days left to register for Shawn's narrative in business workshop in Boston on March 29.)

And Garr Reynolds of the great Presentation Zen blog breaks down the video and summarizes each section.

Storytelling is everywhere.

, ,