Monday, January 22, 2007

Dave Stein and I talk about segmentation

Dave Stein of ES Research recently interviewed yours truly on sales channel segmentation. You can find the resulting post here.

I met Dave almost ten years ago when he conducted a sales and marketing training program for Alltel, where I worked at the time. I was impressed by his matter-of-fact approach and ability to distill the issues around sales and marketing so they didn't seem so difficult to solve.

ES Research provides information and research on sales methodologies and training programs--kind of a Gartner for sales education. They offer by subscription white papers, process methodologies, etc., for companies looking to improve their sales effectiveness. Check them out if you're looking to adopt a new methodology or want to investigate alternatives to your current one.

, , ,

The sneaky price increase - should you use it for business services?

Harvard Business School's Working Knowledge site has just republished a fascinating piece from 2004 in which HBS marketing professor John Gourville tells us something we should already know, but don't:

Consumer products companies "raise prices" on us constantly by reducing the quantity of product they sell for a certain price. (Examples: coffee, breakfast cereal, ice cream.)

Prof. Gourville maintains that these companies have found that reducing quantity while retaining the price point works better than keeping quantity constant and increasing price.

Companies selling technology services to businesses face similar issues--underlying costs (typically labor and benefits) rise, yet customers don't want to pay more. It's even more of a challenge, since tech buyers have come to expect prices to decline for the products and services they buy.

One way to implement the sneaky price increase in business is to reduce the service level of an offering (say, the maintenance response times or the hours tech support is available) and keeping the same price. Yet these items are frequently contracted and not able to be altered freely. Also, the people pushing back on price (procurement or finance) are typically different from the people using the service (IT or operations).

As opposed to the sneaky price increase, many services companies would be better off using a tool that they already have at their disposal--the regular, small, price increase. Many contracts allow the supplier to change price at certain periods of time (often yearly), yet many companies don't use this tool. As a result, prices don't change for years--and then, when a price increase is unavoidable, it's surprising and painful to the customer.

So, negotiate the ability to raise price into your services contracts. And then, use that ability regularly, in small doses. Your customer relationships will be better for it, as well as your bottom line.

(Picture: the former 1-lb. tin of Maxwell House coffee from homegrocer.com)

, , ,

Friday, January 19, 2007

Business bloggers, stop relying on Godin and Kawasaki for your material

A Friday-afternoon rantTM

Is anyone else getting tired of the many business blogs that lard themselves with reductive copies of Seth Godin and Guy Kawasaki posts?

The posts look something like this:

I was reading Seth's blog today and he said [fill in the blank]. He is SO right! Way to go Seth!
or
Guy Kawasaki's recent post on [fill in the blank], really hit home with me. He points out [main idea of original blog post]. I agree with Guy 100%!

Usually there's a picture to fill out the space, and "Digg It" and "del.icio.us" icons.

Why do people do this? The charitable explanation is that writing several blog posts a week is difficult, and recycling high-quality material helps to fill in the inspirational dry stretches.

A more cynical view is: if I can write a post that has lots of links to highly popular blogs like Seth's and Guy's, then those foolish search engines will list my blog when people are actually looking for information on Seth or Guy. And perhaps someone will click on the link, upping my traffic statistics.

, ,

Why do people love fashon but hate to admit it?

The Wall Street Journal yesterday published an article by Alessandra Galloni featuring a fascinating interview with Miuccia Prada, head of the fashion company bearing her name. Ms. Prada has done a lot of thinking about women's love-hate relationship with fashion. (There may be fewer men so afflicted, but it's not an insignificant number. Just go to any bar in New York City and see.)

Ms. Prada can articulate why people are drawn to fashion better than anyone I can think of. Here are a couple of her best quotes from the article:

"Fashion enthralls everyone, from the taxi driver to the mega-intellectual.... Some say it's about seduction, but I think that's limiting," said Ms. Prada, wearing a springy flared skirt and sandals. "What you wear is how you present yourself to the world, especially today, when human contacts are so quick. Fashion is instant language."

"Buying a $5,000 handbag just because it's a status symbol is a sign of weakness," Ms. Prada said. "Daring to wear something different takes effort. And being elegant isn't easy. You have to study it, like cuisine, music and art."

The Journal has posted the entire interview transcript.

, , , ,

Thursday, January 18, 2007

More more storytelling

Self-promotion alert! Stop reading now if you don't want to be sold to.

Okay, now that I have your attention, the two storytelling posts I did in December (here and here) were among the most read of the year.

I also was intrigued by the application of storytelling to business. Via those posts, I connected with Shawn Callahan of Anecdote, a narrative-focused consultancy in Australia. Shawn and his team have taken the narrative approach and created a very pragmatic use for it within business.

In a nutshell, Shawn teaches managers and executives to find the stories in their organizations, make sense out of them, and make changes as a result of what they learned. Anecdote's methods build upon techniques and models originally developed for use at IBM.

Stories, as opposed to metrics or surveys, are the only way you can really learn how complex changes are affecting your employees, so you can make adjustments and improve the outcomes. Complex changes include mergers or acquisitions, reorganizations, deployment of new enterprise technology, process reengineering, outsourcing/offshoring, etc.

Think of the failure rate of those types of projects--wouldn't you want an effective tool to improve your chances of success?

I've been working with Shawn to arrange Anecdote's first workshops in the USA. We will be holding one-day workshops in Seattle on Monday, March 26 and in Boston on Thursday, March 29. The workshops are a great opportunity to get your hands dirty and learn how to extract the key stories from your organization.

If I've whet your appetite at all, please read here for a more detailed overview of the workshop and instructions on how to sign up. And please by all means pass this note along to anyone who might find value in this type of learning.

End of advertisement. Thanks for listening.

, , , ,

Wednesday, January 17, 2007

Courage in business doesn't take b**ls

In the current Harvard Business Review, Kathleen Reardon of the University of Southern California made me think twice about courage.

Conventional wisdom would say that courage is an intrinsic personal capability, allowing one to disregard great risk in order to do the right thing. And in matters of life and death, it is often so. But business is different from a rescue mission or a valiant battle.

In fact, says Reardon, business courage isn't in your gut, but in your brain. She states:

In business, courageous action is really a special kind of calculated risk taking. People who become good leaders have a greater than average willingness to make bold moves, but they strengthen their chances of success--and avoid career suicide--through careful deliberation and preparation.... Most great business leaders teach themselves to make high-risk decisions. They learn to do this well over a period of time, often decades.
I think it's useful to make this distinction between personal courage and business courage. First, it allows for the proper separation of, say, the soldier who led her troops through a dangerous mission and the CEO who sold an underperforming division even though people didn't want him to.

Second, it allows us to focus on those things we can do to learn and apply business courage--in Reardon's thinking, setting goals, weighing risks/benefits, timing, managing the power structure and having contingency plans.

, , , , ,

Tuesday, January 16, 2007

Personal networks - useful anywhere

I am an advocate of robust and well-maintained personal networks. Too often, though, the business press has viewed networks as the property of salespeople. Even "Never Eat Alone," the best single guide to building networks, primarily focuses on their benefits for deal-making.

I'm here to tell you that a good personal network is a strong asset whether you're a corporate executive, an engineer or a human-resources professional.

And if you don't believe me, listen to the Harvard Business Review. In the January issue, two different articles discuss the benefit of networks. In "How Leaders Create And Use Networks" (link to abstract), Profs. Herminia Ibarra and Mark Hunter of INSEAD assert that "strategic networking" is an essential component of leadership. Strategic networking is a longer-view, integrated network of friends/colleagues/mentors/proteges, as opposed to more tactical workgroup-oriented operational networks and casual personal networks. Hunter and Ibarra say,

As they step up to the leadership transition, some managers accept their growing dependence on others and seek to transform it into mutual influence. Others dismiss such work as "political" and, as a result, undermine their ability to advance their goals.
Another article, "Firing Back" (link to abstract) by Jeffrey Sonnenfeld of Yale and Andrew Ward of the University of Georgia, discusses the value of strong networks for fired executives. Paradoxically, more distant connections were more useful in positioning the executive for her next job than closer connections. Say Sonnenfeld and Ward,
Through the power of acquaintance networks, you can reach almost anyone within a few steps. Thus, distant acquaintances that don't appear to have any connection to you may prove key to your recovery when you are trying to get back on your feet.
So keep that address book up to date and, better yet, stay in touch. It'll do more for your career than kissing butt, and it's more fun besides.

(Picture from nruboc via stock.xchng)

, , , , , ,

Monday, January 15, 2007

Innovation means doing more with less

Exhibit A: The NFL's New England Patriots. No other sports franchise has created so much success out of scarcity. Yesterday, against the San Diego Chargers, who had the league's best record and nine all-star honorees (vs. one for the Pats--an injustice, but not one to discuss here), the Patriots beat them with creativity, persistence and some luck. But luck, nonetheless, which resulted from their own innovative preparation.

The play of the game was receiver Troy Brown stripping the football from San Diego's Marlon McCree, who had just intercepted a poorly-thrown Tom Brady pass with six minutes to go in the game. The Patriots recovered, and were able to score eleven points in the next four minutes, erasing an 8-point deficit and winning the game.

With the ball in McCree's hands, the game is over. When Brown stripped it away, he gave the Patriots an opportunity, which, like any innovative organization, they capitalized on.

Several seasons ago, with the Pats' defensive secondary having lost several key members to injury, coach Bill Belichick began to have Brown practice, then play, as a defensive back. (Playing both offense and defense is almost never done past high school. ) His two-way play helped the Patriots win their third Super Bowl.

And on Sunday, after Marlon McCree picked off the pass, Brown channeled that inner cornerback, reacted to the ball, and pulled it, and the game, away from the Chargers.

(Picture: the Patriots belt buckle from buckleshop.com)

, , , , ,

Saturday, January 13, 2007

A peek inside executive severance agreements

The outrage over Bob Nardelli's and Hank McKinnell's multi-hundred million dollar severance agreements still hangs like a cloud over US business. But lost in the outrage is exactly how these severance agreements came to be, and why they look the way they look.

The most misleading impression these articles give is that the board of directors decided to reward the outgoing CEO for his years of service, and thus packed his briefcase with stock options, deferred compensation and cash as a way of saying thanks. (Here's one of the only articles I saw that explained the issue clearly.)

Nonsense. They'd prefer in these situations to pay nothing, even to claw back some of the existing millions they'd paid out.

But the severance agreement is signed when the CEO is hired, not when she's fired. In many cases, when the CEO is lured from another company (say, GE), the employment contract--which covers severance--includes "make-goods" for compensation the CEO is leaving behind (like unvested options, pensions, etc.).

When the CEO is fired, the company needs to pay up on these make-goods or other partially-earned awards. It's in the contract--not optional.

And remember, when the employment contract is negotiated, the prospective CEO has a lot of leverage. She'll hire an attorney and a consultant to make sure she's taken care of in case she's terminated for any reason. And it's true that the CEOs have been far better than their boards at negotiating for their own benefit, should the worst happen.

Therefore, the seeds for the negative PR avalanche around severance packages were sown years before, when the CEOs were initially hired.

, , , , , ,

Thursday, January 11, 2007

Cingular an "unpopular distribution partner"...NOT

In his wide-ranging attack on Steve Jobs in today's WSJ Op-Ed article ("iGenius" - $$), Michael Malone hits Cingular with an unwarranted stray shot.

Malone claims that, among Jobs' many mistakes on the iPhone is the selection of Cingular as an "unpopular distribution partner." Which struck me as odd. Unpopular by what measure, and compared to whom? Cingular has the largest subscriber base, a churn rate that is approaching the industry's best (Verizon), and continues to grow at the expense, primarily, of Sprint.

In my opinion, Cingular is stealing a march on Verizon (who I suppose would be Malone's version of a "popular distribution partner"--unless he means Sprint or T-Mobile) in the smartphone market. In addition to the iPhone exclusive, they offer the Samsung Blackjack and the Blackberry Pearl (UPDATE: I forgot the very cool Sony Ericsson Walkman phones), and Verizon doesn't.

Also, Cingular is GSM, meaning the iPhone can be more easily adapted for sale around the world (where GSM is predominant). That's proving to be an advantage to Cingular too.

, , , , , ,

MVNO blog coverage breaks out of its tiny niche

MVNO, one of my favorite topics (much to the consternation of my wife, who asserts persuasively that I haven't been able to explain clearly what the hell it means), is the subject of an excellent post today in Interpublic Group's Future of Media blog.

Except for press-release driven articles in newspaper business sections, coverage of this industry has been limited to the gadget blogs or industry publications. Does this portend MVNO edging toward being a mainstream, long-term viable business? Sprint, for one, hopes so.

, , , ,

More on the underdo strategy

Nowhere is the underdo strategy more active than in computer software. Thanks to Microsoft setting a high bar for pricing (and growing higher--see these new prices for Windows Vista and Office!), or deficient functionality, or both, they've left lots of space for companies to develop products that offer good or better value at a much lower (or zero) price point. Here's a short list:

Do you think Google sees this white space as an opportunity? You bet. They bought Writely and put together Google Docs & Spreadsheets as a way to grow into a market that has been Microsoft's alone. Yet now Microsoft is trapped in the position of the high-price competitor, offering loads of features that no one uses.

In an example of how things have changed, I use exactly two pieces of Microsoft software: Windows XP and Media Player (and that only when I have to).

And I'm not a cutting-edge tech guy, either.

, , , ,

Wednesday, January 10, 2007

Postscript

The prior post was "fermenting" in my mind for a few days before I put it on paper. Yesterday, after reading the article on Basecamp in PDMA Visions for the umpteenth time, I realized something.

I have been using Basecamp for the past month, for a project I'm working on. (My excuse: my colleague set up the project in the software and sent me a link and user id. He casually referred to "Basecamp" in an email or two, which is what triggered my eventual recollection.)

Now that's a simple, straightforward product. You can use it without being aware of doing so!

If you want to create a great new product, do less

Counter-intuitive, right? Sure was to me. We marketers are brainwashed to believe that "better" means more features. But creating value by doing less is the new horizon in product innovation. Just ask Clayton Christensen of Harvard Business School, or Mark Hart, who wrote about the phenomenon in the latest PDMA Visions magazine.

Christensen (the most quoted man in innovation today?) discusses the concept in the December Harvard Business Review, focusing on social services (link - $$). One example cited is MinuteClinic, which started in Minneapolis providing walk-in health services at CVS drugstores (CVS subsequently acquired MinuteClinic).

MinuteClinic treats a finite set of common maladies with nurse practitioners, not doctors, with reasonable cost and a high-level of convenience. Is MinuteClinic service "better" than treatment from the Mayo Clinic? No, but it's good enough, much cheaper and more convenient. That's the "underdo" strategy in a nutshell.

Mark Hart's example is 37signals, a company that evolved an internal need for simple, Internet-based collaborative project management into Basecamp, a product now used by more than 500,000 users and awarded "Best of the Web" by Business Week--even though it does much less than Microsoft Project. Which of course is the point.

(Picture: a Rube Goldberg device from Wilf Ratzburg via stock.xchng)

, , , , ,

Tuesday, January 09, 2007

Startups, ditch your business plan!

The business plan is an entrepreneur's lifeline. It has near-mythic qualities--the ability to distill an entire business into one short (or long) document, the ability to attract investors, the ability, even, to predict the future. (Want to know what a startup's EBITDA will be in 2010? Check Exhibit K.)

In addition to all these things, according to today's Wall Street Journal, it may also be a waste of time. Referring to several studies of startup performance, reporter Kelly Spors cites a study from Inc. magazine showing that nearly two-thirds of fastest-growing startups had rudimentary business plans or no plan at all.

Why is that? One explanation cited is that startups have to be nimble, and if you are too wedded to a business plan, you may stick with a failing concept too long. Or that spending lots of time writing the perfect business plan can cause you to miss the business opportunity.

You must understand the financial model for your business--how will you charge customers? What are your expenses, fixed and variable, and how will your prices cover your costs? What working capital will you need? But, as stated in the Journal article, "it's not always crucial to have the 60-page plan."

If you're considering ditching the business plan, remember one thing. If you're going to ask any institutions for money (VCs, banks, etc.), you're gonna have to have one. But keep it small and simple--and be prepared to change it.

(Picture from broker via stock.xchng)

, , , ,

Monday, January 08, 2007

Software distribution partnerships--got to know what you want

When you set out to form software distribution partnerships, you know one thing at least: you are looking for someone to sell your stuff. Beyond that, though, many companies wade into this phase of partnering with few other things decided.

And that's a problem.

Are you looking for the partner to fulfill any other roles besides sales? Like, say:

  • Installation
  • Systems integration & project management
  • Ongoing account management
  • Providing complementary software
  • First-level maintenance
  • Second-level maintenance

It's important to have a point of view on this, because it will help you narrow down the types of companies who will be good partners (and perhaps more importantly, the types who won't).

Let me describe two partnerships at the extremes of the distributor spectrum:

Partnership 1: the software provider wants the distributor to sell the product, but the software provider will do all the installation work, any integration/customization required, ongoing maintenance.

Partnership 2: the software provider wants to sell a standard platform, and wants the distributor to install, customize, integrate and provide most maintenance (the software provider only provides core product customization and level 3 support for bug fixes to its platform).

These two partnerships will have very different commercial models, legal agreements, training, exclusivity provisions, etc. The type of partners you look for will be very different as well. Partner 1 can sell and doesn't need any other capabilities (e.g., manufacturer's rep). Partner 2 better also have lots of professional services, strong processes, industry domain expertise, a reliable brand name, etc. Partner 1 will need a share of the license revenue, but most of the overall revenue will be yours. Partner 2 will command a much larger share of each customer's spend, but will let you distribute much more widely.

So think about what you want before you start signing up partners. It'll save lots of money and headaches. And you'll sell more stuff, too.

, , , , ,

Thursday, January 04, 2007

The Seven-Man Clock


My wife got me one of these for my 40th birthday, a few years back. It is without doubt the best conversation piece I've ever had in my office. It's a small replica of a large kinetic sculpture which is in Seattle's Pacific Science Center. There are seven small brass people working at various places on the clock--turning cranks, riding escalators then falling down, etc. It makes a fairly loud whirring noise that thankfully fades into the background as you get used to it.

It seems at first that the workers are moving the machine. But, as you stare at the clock, it becomes increasingly clear that, in fact, the machine is moving the workers.

Which reminds me a lot of when I worked for very large companies.

(photo: the seven-man clock from Kinetico Studios and Gordon Bradt)

, , , ,

Wednesday, January 03, 2007

Examples of different partnerships

Continuing from the last post, here is an example of each type of partnership:


Technology partnership:
Pfizer licenses the right to market Scripps Research Institute's drug discoveries.


Joint venture:

Sony and Ericsson combine their mobile phone operations into a jointly-owned company.


Joint marketing agreement:

Sun Microsystems and Quark collaborate to promote and sell Quark's publishing software running on Sun platforms. (Here's an example contract from Sun.)


Referral relationship:

IDT, and Net2Phone, two telephone providers selling different services (long distance and voice-over-IP), refer leads to each other. (Note: partnerships often grow into deeper relationships--the companies subsequently merged.)

(Photo: the Walkman 810 phone from Sony Ericsson)

, , , ,

Tuesday, January 02, 2007

What's a "strategic alliance" or a "partnership" anyway?

When people in business say they want to be your partner, they usually mean this:

I want you to sell my stuff.

In fact, one of the most dispiriting situations in a product manager's career is getting your first great "partner" lead and discovering the inevitable: while you thought they wanted to sell your stuff, in fact they want you to sell their stuff.

There are other partnerships--technology partnerships, where one company uses another's technology as part of its product (in open innovation vernacular, this is often called in-licensing or out-licensing, depending on whether you're using or supplying the technology); joint ventures, where two or more companies share ownership of a third company which develops, manufacturers and/or markets a product; joint marketing relationships, where companies co-invest in marketing but sell side-by-side to customers; and referral relationships, where companies whose products don't overlap refer prospects to each other, sometimes for a fee or other consideration.

But most of the time, we're talking about somebody selling somebody else's stuff. In the next several posts, I'll talk about how to develop and structure that kind of partnership.

(Picture from stock.xchng)

, , , ,

Saturday, December 30, 2006

How will things change when women run our institutions?

Want to predict the future? Look at the demographics. And they say that in the future we'll have many, many more women leaders than we do now: women are 57% of college students, USA Today reported in 2005. They're the majority of medical school students and 45% of law school students, too. So, the days of "old white men" running the place are numbered.

Which has caused me to wonder how that may change our lives. Today's New York Times has a small glimpse ("Madam Speaker, After Her First Year of Firsts.") Christine C. Quinn is one year into her term as the first woman Speaker of the New York City Council, an unruly body of fifty-one representatives which has typically been a vocal adversary of the mayor. Here are some notable quotes from the article:

“She has injected more democracy, with a little ‘d,’ into the Council,” said James S. Oddo, the Republican minority leader, who has known Ms. Quinn since they worked for different council members in the early 1990s. “Every single council member has a say in the budget. Every single council member has the ability to fight for their constituents....”
She first indicated her willingness to work with the mayor three weeks into her term, after he called for restrictions on lobbyists in his annual address to the City Council. Instead of rejecting the idea, since it opened the Council’s inner workings to public scrutiny, she embraced it....

In April, she sought to end the bazaar-like process by which members lobbied the speaker for projects to be included in the city’s operating budget. She required that members limit themselves to four written requests that had the support of nine colleagues from three boroughs....
Then she charmed, cajoled and fought the mayor into considering her call for an end to the so-called budget dance....

“I find that if we disagree, she’s very, very clear,” said Simcha Felder, a Brooklyn councilman. “I don’t walk out of the room thinking she said yes but she means no....”
It's dangerous to generalize from one person's experience to an entire gender, but if more women in power means more collaboration, more effective negotiation between opposing parties and more disciplined political processes, then I'm for it.

, , , , ,

Thursday, December 28, 2006

What I'm reading now...

I saw this book at Barnes & Noble last week while buying a Christmas present. (Orange cover, memorable title in a huge typeface--great marketing.) I was skeptical--most business books, especially ones that seem this sales-y, turn out to be poorly-written rehashes of business cliches or outdated ideas.

Not this one.

It's well-written, and the subject is very important to any executive or entrepreneur: how to discover, nurture and build relationships. What Keith Ferrazzi reveals is that with good and deep relationships one can make and close great deals. And without them, it's tough sledding indeed. (Usefully, he also tells you how not to be a "networking jerk"--a mercenary who collects business cards like big game trophies, not caring a whit about the people who carry the cards.)

The style is that of a how-to book, but with lots of concrete examples, using real names. I could have done without the "Connectors' Hall-of-Fame Profiles," where legendary networkers such as Vernon Jordan and Bill Clinton are discussed--it almost seemed as if that was a suggestion from the publisher rather than an organic component of the book. But that's a small complaint.

You also get a good sense of the author, and he's very likable. You realize quickly why he has so many useful and valuable relationships.

So pick up this book. It might help you create some new and valuable relationships.

And there's a related blog.

,
, , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, December 27, 2006

Fortune 500 Corporate Blog Review: EDS (#108) part 2

This review is for the Fortune 500 Corporate Blog project. As I mentioned in the earlier EDS blog post, I worked for Electronic Data Systems (NYSE: EDS), in its Telecommunications Strategic Business Unit, between 1992 and 1997.

This is the second EDS corporate blog I've reviewed. (Here's the other.)

Name: "The Goal: Customer Service In The IT Industry."

History: regular posts since June 2006.

Frequency of posts: Not a lot. Two-three per month, decreasing from a high of seven in June, and none since November 7. See, here's what happens with blogs with infrequent posts. It generates questions, such as: has Kim Stevenson, the only poster, gotten very busy? Has she left the company? Or lost interest in the blog? The lack of new content on the blog is important to EDS, because their blogs are a reflection of the company, its people and its insight. The last thing EDS (which has upwards of 100,000 employees) wants to convey is: we have nothing to say.

Nature of posts: Customer service in the IT industry. It's a great topic; not covered much elsewhere, and very nicely done. The posts have a definite point of view, are well-constructed, and reflect the voice of a single author. [But please give us more of them!]

Design/functionality: Like The Next Big Thing, text, text and more text. It uses the same template, with EDS website tabs and links. No references to external blogs or resources (other than in the posts), which is sending another message--EDS is not curious about the outside world, and has all the insight they need inside the company. (I hope I'm wrong.)

Kim Stevenson, EDS' Vice President of Infrastructure Service Delivery, writes all the posts. I like the integrity and consistency that results from a single author, but I don't like the scanty posts (have I said that twice already?).

Links etc.: The blog is unclaimed in Technorati and is ranked #1,563,799, but #25,018 on Alexa. With more posts and some time, it would certainly get a lot more links.

So, EDS... let's get Kim some help in her department so she has more time to make "The Goal" everything it can be!

, , ,

Saturday, December 23, 2006

Goodbye to another innovator

I learned in this New York Times article that Peter McColough, a longtime CEO and chairman of Xerox, died last week. (UPDATE: The Wall Street Journal has a bittersweet remembrance in their December 23 issue.)

He oversaw Xerox during the late '60's and throughout the '70's, when it emmerged as one of the most successful companies in the world via its creation and popularization of xerography--i.e., the copying machine.

But perhaps his most enduring legacy is his creation of the Palo Alto Research Center in 1970. PARC was responsible for bringing into use some useful tools that you are using RIGHT NOW--the mouse, Ethernet and the graphical user interface. (For a taste of what PARC is thinking about now, click here.)

That Xerox never profited much from these innovations should not diminish PARC's importance, nor Mr. McColough's legacy.

(picture: Ethernet cable by Hilary via stock.xchng)

, , , , , , ,

Thursday, December 21, 2006

Top 10 best articles of the year

Wrapping up the year with a final best-of list. These were the best, most inspirational, funniest or otherwise most interesting things I read this year in magazines, newspapers or scholarly journals. (Upon reflection, there isn't a funny one in the bunch. Better luck next year!)

Sadly, most of these articles cost $$ or require a paid subscription. They're worth a few dollars, though, if you haven't read them. Enjoy!

10. "Primer on 'Open Innovation,'" Michael Docherty, PDMA Visions, April.

9. "Asking, 'What Would Ann Do?'" Amy Merrick, Wall Street Journal, September 15.

8. "Strategies To Fight Low-Cost Rivals," Nirmalya Kumar, Harvard Business Review, December.

7. "Innovating Through Design," Roberto Verganti, Harvard Business Review, December.

6. "Maybe We Should Leave That Up To The Computer," Douglas Heingartner, New York Times, 18 July.

5. "Internet Encyclopaedias Go Head To Head," Jim Giles, Nature, 15 December 2005.

4. "I'm OK, You're Biased," Dan Gilbert, New York Times, April 16.

3. "Out To Maximize Social Gains, Not Profit," Vikas Bajaj, New York Times, 8 December.

2. "Innovation: The Classic Traps," Rosabeth Moss Kanter, Harvard Business Review, November.

1. "The Perfect Payday," Charles Forelle and James Bandler, Wall Street Journal, 18 March. Remember options backdating? This is what started it all.

, , , , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, December 20, 2006

Top 10 (actually 11) Shop Talk Posts for 2006

Continuing our look back at 2006 with the best posts (though who am I to judge?) from Shop Talk this year. Feel free to agree, disagree, shoot these down, or call them all unworthy of a best-of list. Cheers.

11. "Passion beats resources every time," November 28.

10. "Successful innovation takes PIEER," August 15.

9. "Vince the fashion label: lessons in building a brand," September 14; and its related post, "Vince sells out," September 28.

8. "If you want to innovate, get some rest," October 4.

7. "Make some mistakes and profit from it," June 21.

6. "Ending the war between sales and marketing," July 6.

5. "A bit of foolishness," October 10.

4. "What in hell is the fuzzy front end?" July 25.

3. "Storytelling in business--and I don't mean fudging the numbers," November 30, and "More storytelling--this time listening," December 5.

2. "Kanter's Innovation Pyramid," November 8.

And the winner, who will be represent the blog at public functions, charity events and local TV appearances for the next twelve months (in case of illness or injury, the runner-up will assume the role of blog representative):

1. "Building business alliances: lessons from 'Miami Vice,'" August 1.

, , , , , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, December 19, 2006

Top 10 favorite posts of the year

'Tis the season for Top 10 lists. I'm working on three--in addition to this one, a list of the newspaper/magazine/journal articles that most influenced me this year and the posts of the year from this blog. So stay tuned. And if you like this list, spread the love--do your own top 10 list!

10. "Why are referrals the BEST KIND of sales lead?" Landing The Deal. Poster: Dan Tudor.

9. "Designing for experience: webinar," PDMA Blog. Poster: Montie Roland.

8. "Advice for a freshman," Blogspotting. Poster: Stephen Baker.

7. "I agree with Tom. And yet...," The Impact of IT on Businesses and their Leaders. Poster: Andrew McAfee.

6. "Why economists like immigration," Greg Mankiw's Blog. Poster: Greg Mankiw.

5. "10 Awesome Places To Get Free Images For Your Blog," BusinessBlogWire. Poster: Easton Ellsworth. (Where do you think I got the picture at the top of this post?)

4. "The Open Space Fishbowl - A new way to an energised conversation," Anecdote. Poster: Andrew Rixon.

3. "Add a 2x12 to your foundation," Duct Tape Marketing. Poster: John Jansch.

2. "Iqbal Quadir on TEDTalks: the difference one cell phone can make to a village...," TEDBlog. Poster: June Cohen. (Honorable mention: "Malcolm Gladwell on TEDTalks." Honorable honorable mention: "Happiness Expert Dan Gilbert on TEDTalks."

Drum roll, please... bhrrrrrrrrrr...

1. "Gary Hamel: the importance of continuous management innovation," The Business Innovation Insider. Poster: Dominic Basulto. (Honorable mention: "The difference between design and craft" from the same blog.)

(Picture from abimages via stock.xchng.)

, , , , , , , , ,

Monday, December 18, 2006

A product leaps from the virtual world to the real

Surprise! This is not a post about Second Life.

Rather, according to this New York Times article, a plot element of the cable TV show "The L Word," about the lives and interactions of a group of women, will be evolved into a full-fledged social network for lesbians.

Says the Times:

From the first season of Showtime’s “The L Word,” a chart mapping the relationships of the character Alice has been a central motif, growing to take over an entire wall.

And now it's grown into cyberspace as well, ready for new-subscriber signup as of January 7. Some of the key actors in the show are partners in the site, called OurChart.com, as is Showtime. (Here's a map of the chart that will serve as the site's logo.)

You could call it product out-placement.

, , , ,

Friday, December 15, 2006

Friday comix - FAO Schwartz's revival


"Recently, Mr. Schmults has placed a big emphasis on the FAO Schwarz-created toys -- commissioned and branded by the company. Meticulous by nature, Mr. Schmults is determined to make sure they are durable and desirable -- and not sold anywhere else." - The Wall Street Journal, "Reviving FAO Schwartz"

, , , , ,

Thursday, December 14, 2006

Fortune 500 Corporate Blog Review: EDS (#108)

First, full disclosure: I worked for Electronic Data Systems (NYSE: EDS), in its Telecommunications Strategic Business Unit, between 1992 and 1997.

On to the review. I'd like to compliment EDS, first of all, on making its corporate blogs easy to find. You can reach this summary link right from the eds.com home page. Excellent!

There are two blogs. The first contains insights and opinions from EDS fellows (its best and brightest technical minds) on the future of technology. We'll discuss that one here. A future post will discuss the other (quite different) blog, "The Goal: Customer Service In The IT Industry."

Name: "The Next Big Thing"

History: regular posts since June 2005.

Frequency of posts: Fifteen to twenty per month.

Nature of posts: Opinions regarding current technology trends and news. There was no mention in any of the posts that I read (a dozen or so) of EDS' business at all. The "sales pitch" quotient was therefore a big zero--good. If it doesn't quite live up to its advertisement as "an unfiltered vehicle for some of our leading technology experts to candidly discuss trends, attitudes and the impact of technology on our lives," there are at least firm points of view (see this post on the Zune MP3 player). They're not afraid to go far afield of their domain expertise, making for a nicely eclectic blog--if you'd like to read some thoughts inspired by moon colonization, click here.

Design/functionality: Easy to read, which is good because it's all text--no graphics at all. It's subtly integrated with the EDS website (a smart touch), with tabs and links to key items on that website. While there are lots of external links within the posts, the blog layout itself is highly internal--there is no blogroll, reading list or any acknowledgement of relevant outside thought. That's telling, I think.

Offers RSS and atom feeds. They allow comments (moderated) but no trackbacks. The administrator is not identified. There are several different posters.

I liked that they published their blogging guidelines.

Links etc.: The blog is unclaimed in Technorati and is ranked #119,158. Technorati's information is a couple of weeks out of date.

, , ,

Wednesday, December 13, 2006

Worst practices in customer service #2

The final step in completing our house renovation project is installing new smoke detectors, motion sensors and door & window sensors to the new parts of the house. For this part of the job, we called our local alarm company, where we've been a customer for five years, having paid them over $2000 during this time for their installation and monitoring services.

Fast-forward two months. They've blown off four (4) appointments. Numerous calls to customer service have done nothing. So my wife calls the owner of the company. Surely he will resolve the situation quickly--after all, it's his name on the door.

But he doesn't want to hear our complaints. Instead, he takes up time on the call letting us know about the emergency call they had at the health center last night, and the customer who was raped.

Important issues, no doubt, but not relevant to our situation. Why did they miss the appointments? Why didn't they call to let us know? Don't they value us as customers? He doesn't want to review what has happened--he just wants to "move forward."

By the end of the call, he is practically begging us to take our deposit back and go to another supplier.

Hello ADT!

(Pass along the worst practices you've seen--help make this a continuing feature!)

, ,

Tuesday, December 12, 2006

"Business first" at a trade show: a cautionary tale

More than ten years ago, we were preparing for our largest trade show of the year. Our sales & marketing team had been absorbing solution-selling lessons all year, and we were determined to quickly weed out poor leads, only respond to RFP's where we had the inside track, and, certainly, not waste time with unqualified prospects at this trade show.

So we came up with a slogan: "Business First." Our booth was to be a showcase of our product and solution prowess, and only interested prospects, and decisionmakers at that, would be allowed past our gauntlet of booth staffers. No tire-kickers, no freebie-searchers. Certainly no competitors.

We got to the show terribly excited, and eager to lock down a set of leads that would ensure our sales success for the rest of the year. We set up the large booth and the demo systems, hung our posters, wore our business suits--not polo shirts and khakis. We looked great.

And no one came. Our booth featured a group of uncomfortable people milling around, wearing suits, saying nothing. Even the few prospects we managed to draw in were spooked by how quiet and downbeat it was. As I walked the floor, several people asked me if we were exhibiting at the show.

We never did that again.

The lessons we took away: always make the booth fun; have something to give away; encourage people (even non-prospects) to visit and spend time; and don't take it too seriously.

There are lots of how-to tipsheets on the internet about trade shows--this one was the best of the ones I surveyed.

(picture: my favorite booth giveaway ever--a CD/DVD opening tool)

, , ,

Monday, December 11, 2006

An alternate approach to product innovation: the Lombardy design cluster

Tired of reading about open innovation? According to Professor Roberto Verganti in this month's Harvard Business Review (link to article), the Lombardy design cluster--a closely-linked group of furniture, lighting, and kitchen products companies in northern Italy--uses a different method to create their innovative products: what he calls "innovation through design."

Dr. Verganti is a favorite of this blog (here's a prior post), and I really like that he mines the industries of his native Italy for lessons that can apply world-wide.

In this case, he studies radically fashion-forward companies such as Alessi, the home furnishings maker famous for the Michael Graves teakettle pictured above. Alessi and its Lombardy cohorts don't try to poll users to see what they need, nor do they rely on new technology to push their products forward. Instead, they ask designers, frequently architects, to come together in intense dialogue to create products that are leaps ahead of today's products.

The designs in some ways appear to be dreams of the future--creating products so new and fresh that they can remain fashionable for a generation or more (that teakettle design is more than twenty years old). See the Kartell Bookworm moldable bookshelf for another example. Products created this way, by this group, aren't only interesting. They're also profitable. According to Dr. Verganti, furniture companies in this cluster outgrew the average European Union furniture maker by nearly a factor of seven.

Here are other companies in the Lombardy cluster as cited by Dr. Verganti:

(Picture: the iconic 9093 teakettle from Alessi)

, , , , , ,

Saturday, December 09, 2006

Another inspiring thought from Dr. Yunus

Mr. Muhammad Yunus, the 2006 Nobel Peace Prize winner, is interviewed in today's New York Times.

I was struck in particular by how he answered a question about the increasing number of college-educated Bangladeshis, in part created by Grameen Bank scholarship programs. How do you deal with the situation, he is asked, where there may be more college graduates than jobs available to employ them?

My response [to students who worry about this question] is: “...Yes, I understand your position, but I have a different view. As Grameen Bank children, you should have your...own pledge about your life. And the pledge you make, you repeat every morning: I shall never ask for a job from anybody. I will create jobs.”

, , , , ,

Friday, December 08, 2006

What is the cost of our inability to be present in the moment?

Any parent will tell you that kids are the first to notice things, and, according to today's Wall Street Journal, the same is true with the downside of our multitasking world--specifically, how the always-available email tool of choice, the Blackberry, continually distracts us from the here and now.

I think Blackberry addiction (the article outlines some warning signs and also offers tools to treat the addiction) is a bad thing, period. And I say that as someone who has had a Blackberry for several years and who has fallen victim to this syndrome more than once.

The benefits of the Blackberry are legion. But its convenience comes at a price. When you're checking your email, or responding to an email, or thinking about checking an email, you're working. And when you're working, you're not eating dinner with the family, or playing with your kids. And there's a cost to this--not only a personal cost. At work, email-itis can make your meetings less effective, your managing less effective, your team less effective.

There's a balance to be struck, and we need to work on it. I need to work on it.

Gotta run. An email just came in.

, ,

Friday comix - the Happiness Home (tm)


Some key features:

  • Large parlor and kitchen, for entertaining friends*
  • Celebration center to keep trophies, photos and keepsakes to "cherish the moment a little longer"*
  • Home office to cut out that nasty commute*
  • And, to make things simple, this floor plan comes in one configuration only--no stressing over choices!*
* key elements of a happy life as described in this Wall Street Journal article.

, , , ,

Thursday, December 07, 2006

Fortune 500 Corporate Blog Review: Interpublic Group (#348)


Interpublic Group (NYSE: IPG) is the third-largest advertising/marketing holding company in the world. So they know something about blogs. The closest thing to a "corporate" blog they have is from their Emerging Media Lab, so that's what we'll talk about.

Name: "The Future of Media"

History: regular posts since June 2006.

Frequency of posts: About eight per month.

Nature of posts: Unsurprisingly, the blog deals with the future of media. Post subjects include Second Life, mobile advertising, video games, etc.. They present good analyses of fake user-created content here and here. As befits a research lab, there's no overt selling in the blog. Just talking about what's happening in new media, and why.

Design/functionality: A nice, clean design, with good use of graphics (as one would expect). The text is well organized and formatted. The left column includes categories, recent comments, frequently used tags, a blogroll and a reading list. In short, a very professional-looking blog. Offers an RSS feed. They allow comments (unmoderated, but requiring email verification) and trackbacks. The administrator is not identified. There are a handful of different posters, but Jeff Berg is responsible for more than half the posts.

Links etc.: The blog is unclaimed in Technorati and is ranked #223,757. Technorati's information is more than six weeks out of date. There are a few links from other blogs, mostly small ones.

A good blog on a timely topic. I will add "The Future of Media" to my reading list. Thanks, guys.

, , ,

Wednesday, December 06, 2006

Low-price companies change consumer behavior permanently

There's a very interesting article in this month's Harvard Business Review entitled "Strategies to Fight Low-Cost Rivals" by London Business School professor Nirmalya Kumar. It's got lots to say about how traditional companies can compete with low-price insurgents.

Within the article, however, are several passages that will send chills up the back of any marketer. Customers will pay more for more value, correct? Prof. Kumar says yes, to a point. But he also says this:

My research suggests that if a business gets a customer to buy its products or services on the basis of price, it will lose the customer only if a rival offers a lower price.

So once a customer defects to a low-price rival, she ain't coming back.

Well, how about the marketer's favorite tool, feature differentiation? That can help, can't it? Says Prof. Kumar:

Many companies find it tough to persuade consumers to pay for additional benefits. A small premium for greater services or benefits is a powerful defense, as Target and Walgreens have shown.

With the emphasis on small. The marketer's toolbag certainly has shrunk. Thanks Wal-Mart, Dell, Southwest, Huawei!

, , , ,

Tuesday, December 05, 2006

More stories--this time, listening

After my post last week about storytelling in business, I received a nice comment from Shawn Callahan of the Anecdote blog about using stories in business another way--about collecting and making sense of stories to understand deeply what's happening in a company. Shawn's ideas are summarized here.

Imagine that your company has recently reorganized. Deep in the organization many disruptions ensue. But what exactly is happening, and how do people really feel about it? Without this basic information it's impossible to assess the impact of the change, and how to mitigate the negative effects of the change.

Stories can help. Getting employees to describe in detail what is happening to them, without imposing limitations such as predetermined hypotheses, closed-ended questions, numerical ratings, etc.--yields much deeper insights (here's a neat white paper from Anecdote describing how this works). And from those insights, a company can design effective responses to improve the work environment and help an important change take root.

Thanks, Shawn, for pointing this out.

(Picture: the listening ear from sailortownbelfast.org)

, ,

Monday, December 04, 2006

A very brief history of wheeled luggage

At the session on Sustainable Innovation at last week's Fortune Innovation Forum, William McDonough, the green architect and designer, said the following:

"Mankind isn't so smart. It took us 5,000 years to put wheels on luggage."

Which got me to thinking about the history of wheeled luggage, so here is the best history you can get on the subject based on a brief survey of the (internet-hosted) literature:

circa 1851: In "Moby-Dick," Queequeg talls the story of strapping his seachest to a wheelbarrow but then, not knowing how to maneuver the barrow, gathers the whole assembly and carries it.

very early 1900's: steamer trunks with two wheels are advertised.

1970's: wheels appear on traditional suitcases; travelers pulling them by leashes and poorly balanced suitcases toppling over ensue.

1989: Northwest Airlines pilot Bob Plath develops the roll-aboard suitcase for flight crews.

Today: wheels on everything. Soon we will be porting luggage at our front, back and sides, cocooned in storage, like Manhattanites walking their dogs.

(Picture: the TravelPro Crew5 series, via London Luggage)


, , , ,

Saturday, December 02, 2006

Is Microsoft innovative?

In case you missed it, there's a nice article in yesterday's Wall Street Journal featuring a dialogue between Robert Scoble and Dave Winer over whether Microsoft is an innovative company. Given the many shots leveled at Microsoft at the Fortune Innovation Forum this week, it's a timely read.

, , ,